问题
I have a question about the sgolay function in Matlab R2013a. My database has 165 spectra with 2884 variables and I would like to take the first and second derivatives of them. How might I define the inputs K and F to sgolay?
Below is an example:
sgolay is used to smooth a noisy sinusoid and compare the resulting first and second derivatives to the first and second derivatives computed using diff. Notice how using diff amplifies the noise and generates useless results.
K = 4; % Order of polynomial fit
F = 21; % Window length
[b,g] = sgolay(K,F); % Calculate S-G coefficients
dx = .2;
xLim = 200;
x = 0:dx:xLim-1;
y = 5*sin(0.4*pi*x)+randn(size(x)); % Sinusoid with noise
HalfWin = ((F+1)/2) -1;
for n = (F+1)/2:996-(F+1)/2,
% Zero-th derivative (smoothing only)
SG0(n) = dot(g(:,1), y(n - HalfWin: n + HalfWin));
% 1st differential
SG1(n) = dot(g(:,2), y(n - HalfWin: n + HalfWin));
% 2nd differential
SG2(n) = 2*dot(g(:,3)', y(n - HalfWin: n + HalfWin))';
end
SG1 = SG1/dx; % Turn differential into derivative
SG2 = SG2/(dx*dx); % and into 2nd derivative
% Scale the "diff" results
DiffD1 = (diff(y(1:length(SG0)+1)))/ dx;
DiffD2 = (diff(diff(y(1:length(SG0)+2)))) / (dx*dx);
subplot(3,1,1);
plot([y(1:length(SG0))', SG0'])
legend('Noisy Sinusoid','S-G Smoothed sinusoid')
subplot(3, 1, 2);
plot([DiffD1',SG1'])
legend('Diff-generated 1st-derivative', 'S-G Smoothed 1st-derivative')
subplot(3, 1, 3);
plot([DiffD2',SG2'])
legend('Diff-generated 2nd-derivative', 'S-G Smoothed 2nd-derivative')
回答1:
Taking derivatives in an inherently noisy process. Thus, if you already have some noise in your data, indeed, it will be magnified as you take higher order derivatives. Savitzky-Golay is a very useful way of combining smoothing and differentiation into one operation. It's a general method and it computes derivatives to an arbitrary order. There are trade-offs, though. Other special methods exist for data with a certain structure.
In terms of your application, I don't have any concrete answers. Much depends on the nature of the data (sampling rate, noise ratio, etc.). If you use too much smoothing, you'll smear your data or produce aliasing. Same thing if you over-fit the data by using high order polynomial coefficients, K. In your demo code you should also plot the analytical derivatives of the sin function. Then play with different amounts of input noise and smoothing filters. Such a tool with known exact answers may be helpful if you can approximate aspects of your real data. In practice, I try to use as little smoothing as possible in order to produce derivatives that aren't too noisy. Often this means a third-order polynomial (K = 3) and a window size, F, as small as possible.
So yes, many suggest that you use your eyes to tune these parameters. However, there has also been some very recent research on choosing the coefficients automatically: On the Selection of Optimum Savitzky-Golay Filters (2013). There are also alternatives to Savitzky-Golay, e.g., this paper based on regularization, but you may need to implement them yourself in Matlab.
By the way, a while back I wrote a little replacement for sgolay. Like you, I only needed the second output, the differentiation filters, G, so that's all it calculates. This function is also faster (by about 2–4 times):
function G=sgolayfilt(k,f)
%SGOLAYFILT Savitzky-Golay differentiation filters
s = vander(0.5*(1-f):0.5*(f-1));
S = s(:,f:-1:f-k);
[~,R] = qr(S,0);
G = S/R/R';
A full version of this function with input validation is available on my GitHub.
来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/23943080/how-does-the-sgolay-function-work-in-matlab-r2013a