问题
What is the general term for a functor with a structure resembling QuickCheck's promote
function, i.e., a function of the form:
promote :: (a -> f b) -> f (a -> b)
(this is the inverse of flip $ fmap (flip ($)) :: f (a -> b) -> (a -> f b)
). Are there even any functors with such an operation, other than (->) r
and Id
? (I'm sure there must be). Googling 'quickcheck promote' only turned up the QuickCheck documentation, which doesn't give promote
in any more general context AFAICS; searching SO for 'quickcheck promote' produces no results.
回答1:
So far I found these ways of constructing an f
with the promote
morphism:
f = Identity
- if f and g both have
promote
then the pair functorh t = (f t, g t)
also does - if f and g both have
promote
then the compositionh t = f (g t)
also does - if f has the
promote
property and g is any contrafunctor then the functorh t = g t -> f t
has thepromote
property
The last property can be generalized to profunctors g, but then f will be merely a profunctor, so it's probably not very useful, unless you only require profunctors.
Now, using these four constructions, we can find many examples of functors f
for which promote
exists:
f t = (t,t)
f t = (t, b -> t)
f t = (t -> a) -> t
f t = ((t,t) -> b) -> (t,t,t)
f t = ((t, t, c -> t, (t -> b) -> t) -> a) -> t
Also note that the promote
property implies that f
is pointed.
point :: t -> f t
point x = fmap (const x) (promote id)
Essentially the same question: Is this property of a functor stronger than a monad?
回答2:
(<*>) :: Applicative f => f (a -> b) -> f a -> f b
(=<<) :: Monad m => (a -> m b) -> m a -> m b
Given that Monad is more powerful an interface than Applicative, this tell us that a -> f b
can do more things than f (a -> b)
. This tells us that a function of type (a -> f b) -> f (a -> b)
can't be injective. The domain is bigger than the codomain, in a handwavey manner. This means there's no way you can possibly preserve behavior of the function. It just doesn't work out across generic functors.
You can, of course, characterize functors in which that operation is injective. Identity
and (->) a
are certainly examples. I'm willing to bet there are more examples, but nothing jumps out at me immediately.
回答3:
Data.Distributive has
class Functor g => Distributive g where
distribute :: Functor f => f (g a) -> g (f a)
-- other non-critical methods
Renaming your variables, you get
promote :: (c -> g a) -> g (c -> a)
Using slightly invalid syntax for clarity,
promote :: ((c ->) (g a)) -> g ((c ->) a)
(c ->)
is a Functor
, so the type of promote
is a special case of the type of distribute
. Thus every Distributive
functor supports your promote
. I don't know if any support promote
but not Distributive
.
来源:https://stackoverflow.com/questions/26264411/what-is-the-general-case-of-quickchecks-promote-function