问题
I want to ask you about my class diagram. I'm making a class diagram for simple web portal for my weekend university studies. Is it made correctly? What would you change if I you were mine? Use cases you can find here Class diagram from use case diagram.
Should I create each user class separately? I mean Admin class, Redactor class, Moderator class etc. I've used privileges field (see User class) to simulate each user's role. Is it correct?
I imagine that ContentManager class holds User class instance and it is used inside Article, Announcement, Advertisement and Comment class to check whether these action is allowed.
I would be very glad for your answers. Here you can find XML file for WhiteStarUML program my XML file
回答1:
What you should do is create an analysis model of your domain. That model would contain classes like Article, Announcement, etc., as you have in your current diagram. For an example, please refer to another answer I recently posted to someone else's question. The diagram for that answer is shown again here for your convenience:
Notice how the model I provided in that answer has nothing like a UserManager or a ContentManager that just contains code to manipulate other classes. You don't want those, unless people actually play those roles. Notice how it has verb phrases and multiplicities at the ends of every association to tell you why things are related. Notice how there are no mundane CRUD operations on those classes, like create, update, and delete.
Once you have an analysis model in place, then you should allocate actions to the appropriate classes, which will usually mirror your use cases. For example, your Comment class might have an edit() operation. But it might not. You might consider having an operation called replaceComment() in the Article class (if that's how your domain works). I don't know how your domain should work because you are missing an analysis model that teaches it to me!
After you complete an analysis model, then I would make a design model that augments it with solution-domain concerns, such as logging a user into the system. Here is an answer to another question that you may find helpful for moving from analysis to design.
来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/35801987/uml-class-diagram-for-simple-web-portal