问题
I have been creating a short program for implementing Sieve of Eratosthenes. In he program, I have used int startingPoint
which held the value of the current prime number, which had it's multiplications being marked non-prime, starting from its square. I used the pow() function to calculate the square of the starting point in the current loop. While doing so, I came across a weird phenomenon. When startingPoint
was equal to 5
, then after int i = pow(startingPoint,2)
the value of i
was 24, instead of 25. This phenomenon occurred only when startingPoint
was equal to 5. Afterwards, I ran a few tests, that leaded to the following code snippet:
#include <iostream>
#include <math.h>
int main()
{
int p=5;
int num1 = pow(5,2);
int num2 = pow(p,2);
float num3 = pow(p,2);
int num4 = floor(pow(p,2));
std::cout.precision(10);
std::cout<<num1<<std::endl; //25
std::cout<<num2<<std::endl; //24
std::cout<<std::fixed<<num3<<std::endl; //25.0000000000
std::cout<<num4<<std::endl; //25
}
As it can be seen, if I call pow
with int
literals, the result will be the actual square of the number. However, if I call it using int p=5
, then what pow
returns is actually one lower than the expected result. If I pass the result into a float
variable, it also recieves the correct result.
Now, I know the way pow
calculates powers is via approximation, and thus, errors such as this when converting to integer may occur. I might just let it be like that. But what REALLY made me stop and think is what happens with num4
. pow(p,2)
casted to int returns 24. But floor(pow(p,2))
casted to int
returns 25. So the floor
function, which, by standard rounds a number down, somehow makes the returned value cast into a higher integer value.
My question in short: Just how does that happen? (I was using gcc 5.3.0 through MinGW)
Edit: As I already stated in the question, I can accept the reason behind pow
return value being casted into a lower integer value, but what I really can't comprehend (and I haven't seen this being brought up anywhere else either) is how floor
fixes that. How can floor
make the return value of pow
actually cast into a higher integer value? Now THAT is the real question.
来源:https://stackoverflow.com/questions/40453050/pow-returning-wrong-result-under-specific-conditions-and-an-unexpected-fix