How do I sign a PDF with a Smart Card in a web context using iText?

问题

Read through the following references:

iText Digital signature white paper, and C# examples. (specifically chapter 4) For those interested, another great and concise summary of the PDF signing process.
CAPICOM documentation.
Online examples / questions here and on iText mailing list archives, such as here and here.

Hashing code:

BouncyCastle.X509Certificate[] chain = Utils.GetSignerCertChain();
reader = Utils.GetReader();
MemoryStream stream = new MemoryStream();
using (var stamper = PdfStamper.CreateSignature(reader, stream, '\0'))
{
    PdfSignatureAppearance sap = stamper.SignatureAppearance;
    sap.SetVisibleSignature(
        new Rectangle(36, 740, 144, 770),
        reader.NumberOfPages,
        "SignatureField"
    );
    sap.Certificate = chain[0];
    sap.SignDate = DateTime.Now;
    sap.Reason = "testing web context signatures";

    PdfSignature pdfSignature = new PdfSignature(
        PdfName.ADOBE_PPKLITE, PdfName.ADBE_PKCS7_DETACHED
    );
    pdfSignature.Date = new PdfDate(sap.SignDate);
    pdfSignature.Reason = sap.Reason;
    sap.CryptoDictionary = pdfSignature;

    Dictionary<PdfName, int> exclusionSizes = new Dictionary<PdfName, int>();
    exclusionSizes.Add(PdfName.CONTENTS, SIG_BUFFER * 2 + 2);
    sap.PreClose(exclusionSizes);

    Stream sapStream = sap.GetRangeStream();
    byte[] hash = DigestAlgorithms.Digest(
        sapStream,
        DigestAlgorithms.SHA256
    );

// is this needed?
    PdfPKCS7 sgn = new PdfPKCS7(
        null, chain, DigestAlgorithms.SHA256, true
    );
    byte[] preSigned = sgn.getAuthenticatedAttributeBytes(
        hash, sap.SignDate, null, null, CryptoStandard.CMS
    );

    var hashedValue = Convert.ToBase64String(preSigned);
}

Just a simple test - a dummy Pdf document is created on initial page request, hash is calculated, and put in a hidden input field Base64 encoded. (the hashedValue above)

Then use CAPICOM on client-side to POST the form and get user's signed response:

PdfSignatureAppearance sap = (PdfSignatureAppearance)TempData[TEMPDATA_SAP];
PdfPKCS7 sgn = (PdfPKCS7)TempData[TEMPDATA_PKCS7];
stream = (MemoryStream)TempData[TEMPDATA_STREAM];
byte[] hash = (byte[])TempData[TEMPDATA_HASH];

byte[] originalText = (Encoding.Unicode.GetBytes(hashValue));
// Oid algorithm verified on client side
ContentInfo content = new ContentInfo(new Oid("RSA"), originalText);

SignedCms cms = new SignedCms(content, true);
cms.Decode(Convert.FromBase64String(signedValue));
// CheckSignature does not throw exception
cms.CheckSignature(true);
var encodedSignature = cms.Encode();

/* tried this too, but no effect on result
sgn.SetExternalDigest(
    Convert.FromBase64String(signedValue),
    null,
    "RSA"
);
byte[] encodedSignature = sgn.GetEncodedPKCS7(
    hash, sap.SignDate, null, null, null, CryptoStandard.CMS
);
*/
byte[] paddedSignature = new byte[SIG_BUFFER];
Array.Copy(encodedSignature, 0, paddedSignature, 0, encodedSignature.Length);
var pdfDictionary = new PdfDictionary();
pdfDictionary.Put(
    PdfName.CONTENTS,
    new PdfString(paddedSignature).SetHexWriting(true)
);
sap.Close(pdfDictionary);

So right now I'm not sure if I'm messing up hashing part, signature part, or both. In signature code snippet above and in client code (not shown) I'm calling what I think is signature verification code, but that may be wrong too, since this is a first for me. Get the infamous "Document has been altered or corrupted since it was signed" invalid signature message when opening the PDF.

Client-side code (not authored by me) can be found here. Source has a variable naming error, which was corrected. For reference, CAPICOM documentation says signed response is in PKCS#7 format.

EDIT 2015-03-12:

After some nice pointers from @mkl and more research, it seems CAPICOM is practicably unusable in this scenario. Although not documented clearly, (what else is new?) according to here and here, CAPICOM expects a utf16 string (Encoding.Unicode in .NET) as input to create a digital signature. From there it either pads or truncates (depending which source in previous sentence in correct) whatever data it receives if the length is an odd number. I.e. signature creation will ALWAYS FAIL if the Stream returned by PdfSignatureAppearance.GetRangeStream() has a length that is an odd number. Maybe I should create an I'm lucky option: sign if ranged stream length is even, and throw an InvalidOperationException if odd. (sad attempt at humor)

~~For reference, here's the test project~~.

EDIT 2015-03-25:

To close the loop on this, here's a link to a VS 2013 ASP.NET MVC project. May not the be best way, but it does provide a fully working solution to the problem. Because of CAPICOM's strange and inflexible signing implementation, as described above, knew a possible solution would potentially require a second pass and a way to inject an extra byte if the return value of PdfSignatureAppearance.GetRangeStream() (again, Stream.Length) is an odd number. I was going to try the long and hard way by padding the PDF content, but luckily a co-worker found it was much easier to pad PdfSignatureAppearance.Reason. Requiring a second pass to do something with iText[Sharp], is not unprecedented - e.g. adding page x of y for a document page header/footer.

回答1:

Use of PdfPkcs7

The server-side code contains this block after the calculation of the range stream digest and before forwarding data to the web page:

PdfPKCS7 sgn = new PdfPKCS7(
    null, chain, DigestAlgorithms.SHA256, true
);
byte[] preSigned = sgn.getAuthenticatedAttributeBytes(
    hash, sap.SignDate, null, null, CryptoStandard.CMS
);

var hashedValue = Convert.ToBase64String(preSigned);

In the case at hand this is not necessary. It is needed only if the external signing API you use merely returns a signed digest; in that case the PdfPKCS7 instance builds the CMS/PKCS#7 signature container. You, on the other hand, use an API for which you know

CAPICOM documentation says signed response is in PKCS#7 format.

Thus, you don't need and (more to the point) must not use the PdfPKCS7 instance.

What does sign.js sign

The content of the server-side hash variable already is the hash digest value of the data to sign. Thus, the frontend, i.e. the sign.js used there, must not hash it again to get the message digest attribute value to put into the signature.

But sign.js signing methods for IE eventually execute

var signedData = new ActiveXObject("CAPICOM.SignedData");

// Set the data that we want to sign
signedData.Content = src;

SignedData.Content, on the other hand, is documented as

Content Read/write Data to be signed.

(msdn: "SignedData object")

So the hash from the backend is used as data to be signed and not as hash of the data to be signed, you indeed hash twice and so have the wrong hash value there.

Thus, it looks like you have to transmit the whole ranged stream which is not really practical...

"But there used to be signing samples using CAPICOM..."

Indeed some old iTextSharp (version 4.x) signing example used CAPICOM. But that code only worked because it created signatures of PDF signature type adbe.pkcs7.sha1 for which a SHA1 hash of the ranged stream indeed is the data embedded in and signed by the PKCS#7 signature.

This is no real option anymore because

it requires the use of SHA1 which in serious contexts is invalid, and
its use has been discouraged at least since ISO 32000-1 (2008) and will be officially deprecated in ISO 32000-2 (under development).

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/28949243/how-do-i-sign-a-pdf-with-a-smart-card-in-a-web-context-using-itext

标签

itext

activex

digital-signature

smartcard

capicom