问题
Firstly here is the problem:
A positive integer is called a palindrome if its representation in the decimal system is the same when read from left to right and from right to left. For a given positive integer K of not more than 1000000 digits, write the value of the smallest palindrome larger than K to output. Numbers are always displayed without leading zeros.
Input: The first line contains integer t, the number of test cases. Integers K are given in the next t lines.
Output: For each K, output the smallest palindrome larger than K. Example
Input:
2
808
2133
Output:
818
2222
Secondly here is my code:
// I know it is bad practice to not cater for erroneous input,
// however for the purpose of the execise it is omitted
import java.io.BufferedReader;
import java.io.InputStreamReader;
import java.util.Scanner;
import java.lang.Exception;
import java.math.BigInteger;
public class Main
{
public static void main(String [] args){
try{
Main instance = new Main(); // create an instance to access non-static
// variables
// Use java.util.Scanner to scan the get the input and initialise the
// variable
Scanner sc=null;
BufferedReader r = new BufferedReader(new InputStreamReader(System.in));
String input = \"\";
int numberOfTests = 0;
String k; // declare any other variables here
if((input = r.readLine()) != null){
sc = new Scanner(input);
numberOfTests = sc.nextInt();
}
for (int i = 0; i < numberOfTests; i++){
if((input = r.readLine()) != null){
sc = new Scanner(input);
k=sc.next(); // initialise the remainder of the variables sc.next()
instance.palindrome(k);
} //if
}// for
}// try
catch (Exception e)
{
e.printStackTrace();
}
}// main
public void palindrome(String number){
StringBuffer theNumber = new StringBuffer(number);
int length = theNumber.length();
int left, right, leftPos, rightPos;
// if incresing a value to more than 9 the value to left (offset) need incrementing
int offset, offsetPos;
boolean offsetUpdated;
// To update the string with new values
String insert;
boolean hasAltered = false;
for(int i = 0; i < length/2; i++){
leftPos = i;
rightPos = (length-1) - i;
offsetPos = rightPos -1; offsetUpdated = false;
// set values at opposite indices and offset
left = Integer.parseInt(String.valueOf(theNumber.charAt(leftPos)));
right = Integer.parseInt(String.valueOf(theNumber.charAt(rightPos)));
offset = Integer.parseInt(String.valueOf(theNumber.charAt(offsetPos)));
if(left != right){
// if r > l then offest needs updating
if(right > left){
// update and replace
right = left;
insert = Integer.toString(right);
theNumber.replace(rightPos, rightPos + 1, insert);
offset++; if (offset == 10) offset = 0;
insert = Integer.toString(offset);
theNumber.replace(offsetPos, offsetPos + 1, insert);
offsetUpdated = true;
// then we need to update the value to left again
while (offset == 0 && offsetUpdated){
offsetPos--;
offset =
Integer.parseInt(String.valueOf(theNumber.charAt(offsetPos)));
offset++; if (offset == 10) offset = 0;
// replace
insert = Integer.toString(offset);
theNumber.replace(offsetPos, offsetPos + 1, insert);
}
// finally incase right and offset are the two middle values
left = Integer.parseInt(String.valueOf(theNumber.charAt(leftPos)));
if (right != left){
right = left;
insert = Integer.toString(right);
theNumber.replace(rightPos, rightPos + 1, insert);
}
}// if r > l
else
// update and replace
right = left;
insert = Integer.toString(right);
theNumber.replace(rightPos, rightPos + 1, insert);
}// if l != r
}// for i
System.out.println(theNumber.toString());
}// palindrome
}
Finally my explaination and question.
My code compares either end and then moves in
if left and right are not equal
if right is greater than left
(increasing right past 9 should increase the digit
to its left i.e 09 ---- > 10) and continue to do
so if require as for 89999, increasing the right
most 9 makes the value 90000
before updating my string we check that the right
and left are equal, because in the middle e.g 78849887
we set the 9 --> 4 and increase 4 --> 5, so we must cater for this.
The problem is from spoj.pl an online judge system. My code works for all the test can provide but when I submit it, I get a time limit exceeded error and my answer is not accepted.
Does anyone have any suggestions as to how I can improve my algorithm. While writing this question i thought that instead of my while (offset == 0 && offsetUpdated) loop i could use a boolean to to make sure i increment the offset on my next [i] iteration. Confirmation of my chang or any suggestion would be appreciated, also let me know if i need to make my question clearer.
回答1:
This seems like a lot of code. Have you tried a very naive approach yet? Checking whether something is a palindrome is actually very simple.
private boolean isPalindrome(int possiblePalindrome) {
String stringRepresentation = String.valueOf(possiblePalindrome);
if ( stringRepresentation.equals(stringRepresentation.reverse()) ) {
return true;
}
}
Now that might not be the most performant code, but it gives you a really simple starting point:
private int nextLargestPalindrome(int fromNumber) {
for ( int i = fromNumber + 1; ; i++ ) {
if ( isPalindrome( i ) ) {
return i;
}
}
}
Now if that isn't fast enough you can use it as a reference implementation and work on decreasing the algorithmic complexity.
There should actually be a constant-time (well it is linear on the number of digits of the input) way to find the next largest palindrome. I will give an algorithm that assumes the number is an even number of digits long (but can be extended to an odd number of digits).
- Find the decimal representation of the input number ("2133").
- Split it into the left half and right half ("21", "33");
- Compare the last digit in the left half and the first digit in the right half.
a. If the right is greater than the left, increment the left and stop. ("22")
b. If the right is less than the left, stop.
c. If the right is equal to the left, repeat step 3 with the second-last digit in the left and the second digit in the right (and so on). - Take the left half and append the left half reversed. That's your next largest palindrome. ("2222")
Applied to a more complicated number:
1. 1234567887654322
2. 12345678 87654322
3. 12345678 87654322
^ ^ equal
3. 12345678 87654322
^ ^ equal
3. 12345678 87654322
^ ^ equal
3. 12345678 87654322
^ ^ equal
3. 12345678 87654322
^ ^ equal
3. 12345678 87654322
^ ^ equal
3. 12345678 87654322
^ ^ equal
3. 12345678 87654322
^ ^ greater than, so increment the left
3. 12345679
4. 1234567997654321 answer
This seems a bit similar to the algorithm you described, but it starts at the inner digits and moves to the outer.
回答2:
Well I have constant order solution(atleast of order k, where k is number of digits in the number)
Lets take some examples suppose n=17208
divide the number into two parts from middle and reversibly write the most significant part onto the less significant one. ie, 17271 if the so generated number is greater than your n it is your palindrome, if not just increase the center number(pivot) ie, you get 17371
other examples
n=17286 palidrome-attempt=17271(since it is less than n increment the pivot, 2 in this case) so palidrome=17371
n=5684 palidrome1=5665 palidrome=5775
n=458322 palindrome=458854
now suppose n = 1219901 palidrome1=1219121 incrementing the pivot makes my number smaller here so increment the number adjacent pivot too 1220221
and this logic could be extended
回答3:
There is no reason to fiddle with individual digits when the only needed operation is one simple addition. The following code is based on Raks' answer.
The code stresses simplicity over execution speed, intentionally.
import static org.junit.Assert.assertEquals;
import java.math.BigInteger;
import org.junit.Test;
public class NextPalindromeTest {
public static String nextPalindrome(String num) {
int len = num.length();
String left = num.substring(0, len / 2);
String middle = num.substring(len / 2, len - len / 2);
String right = num.substring(len - len / 2);
if (right.compareTo(reverse(left)) < 0)
return left + middle + reverse(left);
String next = new BigInteger(left + middle).add(BigInteger.ONE).toString();
return next.substring(0, left.length() + middle.length())
+ reverse(next).substring(middle.length());
}
private static String reverse(String s) {
return new StringBuilder(s).reverse().toString();
}
@Test
public void testNextPalindrome() {
assertEquals("5", nextPalindrome("4"));
assertEquals("11", nextPalindrome("9"));
assertEquals("22", nextPalindrome("15"));
assertEquals("101", nextPalindrome("99"));
assertEquals("151", nextPalindrome("149"));
assertEquals("123454321", nextPalindrome("123450000"));
assertEquals("123464321", nextPalindrome("123454322"));
}
}
回答4:
Here is my code in java. Whole idea is from here http://www.geeksforgeeks.org/given-a-number-find-next-smallest-palindrome-larger-than-this-number/
import java.util.Scanner;
public class Main {
public static void main(String[] args) {
Scanner sc = new Scanner(System.in);
System.out.println("Enter number of tests: ");
int t = sc.nextInt();
for (int i = 0; i < t; i++) {
System.out.println("Enter number: ");
String numberToProcess = sc.next(); // ne proveravam dal su brojevi
nextSmallestPalindrom(numberToProcess);
}
}
private static void nextSmallestPalindrom(String numberToProcess) {
int i, j;
int length = numberToProcess.length();
int[] numberAsIntArray = new int[length];
for (int k = 0; k < length; k++)
numberAsIntArray[k] = Integer.parseInt(String
.valueOf(numberToProcess.charAt(k)));
numberToProcess = null;
boolean all9 = true;
for (int k = 0; k < length; k++) {
if (numberAsIntArray[k] != 9) {
all9 = false;
break;
}
}
// case 1, sve 9ke
if (all9) {
whenAll9(length);
return;
}
int mid = length / 2;
if (length % 2 == 0) {
i = mid - 1;
j = mid;
} else {
i = mid - 1;
j = mid + 1;
}
while (i >= 0 && numberAsIntArray[i] == numberAsIntArray[j]) {
i--;
j++;
}
// case 2 already polindrom
if (i == -1) {
if (length % 2 == 0) {
i = mid - 1;
j = mid;
} else {
i = mid;
j = i;
}
addOneToMiddleWithCarry(numberAsIntArray, i, j, true);
} else {
// case 3 not polindrom
if (numberAsIntArray[i] > numberAsIntArray[j]) { // 3.1)
while (i >= 0) {
numberAsIntArray[j] = numberAsIntArray[i];
i--;
j++;
}
for (int k = 0; k < numberAsIntArray.length; k++)
System.out.print(numberAsIntArray[k]);
System.out.println();
} else { // 3.2 like case 2
if (length % 2 == 0) {
i = mid - 1;
j = mid;
} else {
i = mid;
j = i;
}
addOneToMiddleWithCarry(numberAsIntArray, i, j, false);
}
}
}
private static void whenAll9(int length) {
for (int i = 0; i <= length; i++) {
if (i == 0 || i == length)
System.out.print('1');
else
System.out.print('0');
}
}
private static void addOneToMiddleWithCarry(int[] numberAsIntArray, int i,
int j, boolean palindrom) {
numberAsIntArray[i]++;
numberAsIntArray[j] = numberAsIntArray[i];
while (numberAsIntArray[i] == 10) {
numberAsIntArray[i] = 0;
numberAsIntArray[j] = numberAsIntArray[i];
i--;
j++;
numberAsIntArray[i]++;
numberAsIntArray[j] = numberAsIntArray[i];
}
if (!palindrom)
while (i >= 0) {
numberAsIntArray[j] = numberAsIntArray[i];
i--;
j++;
}
for (int k = 0; k < numberAsIntArray.length; k++)
System.out.print(numberAsIntArray[k]);
System.out.println();
}
}
回答5:
public class NextPalindrome
{
int rev, temp;
int printNextPalindrome(int n)
{
int num = n;
for (int i = num+1; i >= num; i++)
{
temp = i;
rev = 0;
while (temp != 0)
{
int remainder = temp % 10;
rev = rev * 10 + remainder;
temp = temp / 10;
}
if (rev == i)
{
break;
}
}
return rev;
}
public static void main(String args[])
{
NextPalindrome np = new NextPalindrome();
int nxtpalin = np.printNextPalindrome(11);
System.out.println(nxtpalin);
}
}
回答6:
Try this
public static String genNextPalin(String base){
//check if it is 1 digit
if(base.length()==1){
if(Integer.parseInt(base)==9)
return "11";
else
return (Integer.parseInt(base)+1)+"";
}
boolean check = true;
//check if it is all 9s
for(char a: base.toCharArray()){
if(a!='9')
check = false;
}
if(check){
String num = "1";
for(int i=0; i<base.length()-1; i++)
num+="0";
num+="1";
return num;
}
boolean isBasePalin = isPalindrome(base);
int mid = base.length()/2;
if(isBasePalin){
//if base is palin and it is odd increase mid and return
if(base.length()%2==1){
BigInteger leftHalf = new BigInteger(base.substring(0,mid+1));
String newLeftHalf = leftHalf.add(BigInteger.ONE).toString();
String newPalin = genPalin2(newLeftHalf.substring(0,mid),newLeftHalf.charAt(mid));
return newPalin;
}
else{
BigInteger leftHalf = new BigInteger(base.substring(0,mid));
String newLeftHalf = leftHalf.add(BigInteger.ONE).toString();
String newPalin = genPalin(newLeftHalf.substring(0,mid));
return newPalin;
}
}
else{
if(base.length()%2==1){
BigInteger leftHalf = new BigInteger(base.substring(0,mid));
BigInteger rightHalf = new BigInteger(reverse(base.substring(mid+1,base.length())));
//check if leftHalf is greater than right half
if(leftHalf.compareTo(rightHalf)==1){
String newPalin = genPalin2(base.substring(0,mid),base.charAt(mid));
return newPalin;
}
else{
BigInteger leftHalfMid = new BigInteger(base.substring(0,mid+1));
String newLeftHalfMid = leftHalfMid.add(BigInteger.ONE).toString();
String newPalin = genPalin2(newLeftHalfMid.substring(0,mid),newLeftHalfMid.charAt(mid));
return newPalin;
}
}
else{
BigInteger leftHalf = new BigInteger(base.substring(0,mid));
BigInteger rightHalf = new BigInteger(reverse(base.substring(mid,base.length())));
//check if leftHalf is greater than right half
if(leftHalf.compareTo(rightHalf)==1){
return genPalin(base.substring(0,mid));
}
else{
BigInteger leftHalfMid = new BigInteger(base.substring(0,mid));
String newLeftHalfMid = leftHalfMid.add(BigInteger.ONE).toString();
return genPalin(newLeftHalfMid);
}
}
}
}
public static String genPalin(String base){
return base + new StringBuffer(base).reverse().toString();
}
public static String genPalin2(String base, char middle){
return base + middle +new StringBuffer(base).reverse().toString();
}
public static String reverse(String in){
return new StringBuffer(in).reverse().toString();
}
static boolean isPalindrome(String str) {
int n = str.length();
for( int i = 0; i < n/2; i++ )
if (str.charAt(i) != str.charAt(n-i-1))
return false;
return true;
}
回答7:
HI Here is another simple algorithm using python,
def is_palindrome(n):
if len(n) <= 1:
return False
else:
m = len(n)/2
for i in range(m):
j = i + 1
if n[i] != n[-j]:
return False
return True
def next_palindrome(n):
if not n:
return False
else:
if is_palindrome(n) is True:
return n
else:
return next_palindrome(str(int(n)+1))
print next_palindrome('1000010')
回答8:
I have written comments to clarify what each step is doing in this python code.
One thing that need to be taken into consideration is that input can be very large that we can not simply perform integer operations on it. So taking input as string and then manipulating it would be much easier.
tests = int(input())
results = []
for i in range(0, tests):
pal = input().strip()
palen = len(pal)
mid = int(palen/2)
if palen % 2 != 0:
if mid == 0: # if the number is of single digit e.g. next palindrome for 5 is 6
ipal = int(pal)
if ipal < 9:
results.append(int(pal) + 1)
else:
results.append(11) # for 9 next palindrome will be 11
else:
pal = list(pal)
pl = l = mid - 1
pr = r = mid + 1
flag = 'n' # represents left and right half of input string are same
while pl >= 0:
if pal[pl] > pal[pr]:
flag = 'r' # 123483489 in this case pal[pl] = 4 and pal[pr] = 3 so we just need to copy left half in right half
break # 123484321 will be the answer
elif pal[pl] < pal[pr]:
flag = 'm' # 123487489 in this case pal[pl] = 4 and pal[pr] = 9 so copying left half in right half will make number smaller
break # in this case we need to take left half increment by 1 and the copy in right half 123494321 will be the anwere
else:
pl = pl -1
pr = pr + 1
if flag == 'm' or flag == 'n': # increment left half by one and copy in right half
if pal[mid] != '9': # if mid element is < 9 the we can simply increment the mid number only and copy left in right half
pal[mid] = str(int(pal[mid]) + 1)
while r < palen:
pal[r] = pal[l]
r = r + 1
l = l - 1
results.append(''.join(pal))
else: # if mid element is 9 this will effect entire left half because of carry
pal[mid] = '0' # we need to take care of large inputs so we can not just directly add 1 in left half
pl = l
while pal[l] == '9':
pal[l] = '0'
l = l - 1
if l >= 0:
pal[l] = str(int(pal[l]) + 1)
while r < palen:
pal[r] = pal[pl]
r = r + 1
pl = pl - 1
if l < 0:
pal[0] = '1'
pal[palen - 1] = '01'
results.append(''.join(pal))
else:
while r < palen: # when flag is 'r'
pal[r] = pal[l]
r = r + 1
l = l - 1
results.append(''.join(pal))
else: # even length almost similar concept here with flags having similar significance as in case of odd length input
pal = list(pal)
pr = r = mid
pl = l = mid - 1
flag = 'n'
while pl >= 0:
if pal[pl] > pal[pr]:
flag = 'r'
break
elif pal[pl] < pal[pr]:
flag = 'm'
break
else:
pl = pl -1
pr = pr + 1
if flag == 'r':
while r < palen:
pal[r] = pal[l]
r = r + 1
l = l - 1
results.append(''.join(pal))
else:
if pal[l] != '9':
pal[l] = str(int(pal[l]) + 1)
while r < palen:
pal[r] = pal[l]
r = r + 1
l = l - 1
results.append(''.join(pal))
else:
pal[mid] = '0'
pl = l
while pal[l] == '9':
pal[l] = '0'
l = l - 1
if l >= 0:
pal[l] = str(int(pal[l]) + 1)
while r < palen:
pal[r] = pal[pl]
r = r + 1
pl = pl - 1
if l < 0:
pal[0] = '1'
pal[palen - 1] = '01'
results.append(''.join(pal))
for xx in results:
print(xx)
回答9:
Simple codes and test output:
class NextPalin
{
public static void main( String[] args )
{
try {
int[] a = {2, 23, 88, 234, 432, 464, 7887, 7657, 34567, 99874, 7779222, 2569981, 3346990, 229999, 2299999 };
for( int i=0; i<a.length; i++)
{
int add = findNextPalin(a[i]);
System.out.println( a[i] + " + " + add + " = " + (a[i]+add) );
}
}
catch( Exception e ){}
}
static int findNextPalin( int a ) throws Exception
{
if( a < 0 ) throw new Exception();
if( a < 10 ) return a;
int count = 0, reverse = 0, temp = a;
while( temp > 0 ){
reverse = reverse*10 + temp%10;
count++;
temp /= 10;
}
//compare 'half' value
int halfcount = count/2;
int base = (int)Math.pow(10, halfcount );
int reverseHalfValue = reverse % base;
int currentHalfValue = a % base;
if( reverseHalfValue == currentHalfValue ) return 0;
if( reverseHalfValue > currentHalfValue ) return (reverseHalfValue - currentHalfValue);
if( (((a-currentHalfValue)/base)%10) == 9 ){
//cases like 12945 or 1995
int newValue = a-currentHalfValue + base*10;
int diff = findNextPalin(newValue);
return base*10 - currentHalfValue + diff;
}
else{
return (base - currentHalfValue + reverseHalfValue );
}
}
}
$ java NextPalin
2 + 2 = 4
23 + 9 = 32
88 + 0 = 88
234 + 8 = 242
432 + 2 = 434
464 + 0 = 464
7887 + 0 = 7887
7657 + 10 = 7667
34567 + 76 = 34643
99874 + 25 = 99899
7779222 + 555 = 7779777
2569981 + 9771 = 2579752
3346990 + 443 = 3347433
229999 + 9933 = 239932
2299999 + 9033 = 2309032
来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/7934519/a-better-algorithm-to-find-the-next-palindrome-of-a-number-string