问题
I was reading about the GIL and it never really specified if this includes the main thread or not (i assume so). Reason I ask is because I have a program with threads setup that modify a dictionary. The main thread adds/deletes based on player input while a thread loops the data updating and changing data.
However in some cases a thread may iterate over the dictionary keys where one could delete them. If there is a so called GIL and they are run sequentially, why am I getting dict changed errors? If only one is suppose to run at a time, then technically this should not happen.
Can anyone shed some light on such a thing? Thank you.
回答1:
They are running at the same time, they just don't execute at the same time. The iterations might be interleaved. Quote Python:
The mechanism used by the CPython interpreter to assure that only one thread executes Python bytecode at a time.
So two for loops might run at the same time, there will just be no (for example) two del dict[index]'s at the same time.
回答2:
The GIL locks at a Python byte-code level, and applies to all threads, even the main thread. If you have one thread modifying a dictionary, and another iterating keys, they will interfere with each other.
"Only one runs at a time" is true, but you have to understand the unit of granularity. In the case of CPython's GIL, the granularity is a bytecode instruction, so execution can switch between threads at any bytecode.
回答3:
The gil prevents two threads from modifying the interpreter state simultaneously. It doesn't provide any thread consistency constraints, or any kind of mutex at all on a granularity smaller than the whole process. If you need to read and modify a dict in two threads, you should be using a mutex
回答4:
Python switches threads more often than you seem to think it does. You say "only one" is supposed to run at a time, and technically that's true, but it depends on your definition of "one." Python's atomic operations are very small. For example: adding a single item to a dictionary. Iteration over an entire dictionary can be interrupted.
You should use a lock object from the threading library to isolate your program's atomic operations.
来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/4748787/python-threading-and-gil