Scalable or online out-of-core multi-label classifiers

问题

I have been blowing my brains out over the past 2-3 weeks on this problem. I have a multi-label (not multi-class) problem where each sample can belong to several of the labels.

I have around 4.5 million text documents as training data and around 1 million as test data. The labels are around 35K.

I am using scikit-learn. For feature extraction I was previously using TfidfVectorizer which didn't scale at all, now I am using HashVectorizer which is better but not that scalable given the number of documents that I have.

vect = HashingVectorizer(strip_accents='ascii', analyzer='word', stop_words='english', n_features=(2 ** 10))

SKlearn provides a OneVsRestClassifier into which I can feed any estimator. For multi-label I found LinearSVC & SGDClassifier only to be working correctly. Acc to my benchmarks SGD outperforms LinearSVC both in memory & time. So, I have something like this

clf = OneVsRestClassifier(SGDClassifier(loss='log', penalty='l2', n_jobs=-1), n_jobs=-1)

But this suffers from some serious issues:

1. OneVsRest does not have a partial_fit method which makes it impossible for out-of-core learning. Are there any alternatives for that?
2. HashingVectorizer/Tfidf both work on a single core and don't have any n_jobs parameter. It's taking too much time to hash the documents. Any alternatives/suggestions? Also is the value of n_features correct?
3. I tested on 1 million documents. The Hashing takes 15 minutes and when it comes to clf.fit(X, y), I receive a MemoryError because OvR internally uses LabelBinarizer and it tries to allocate a matrix of dimensions (y x classes) which is fairly impossible to allocate. What should I do?
4. Any other libraries out there which have reliable & scalable multi-label algorithms? I know of genism & mahout but both of them don't have anything for multi-label situations?

回答1:

I would do the multi-label part by hand. The OneVsRestClassifier treats them as independent problems anyhow. You can just create the n_labels many classifiers and then call partial_fit on them. You can't use a pipeline if you only want to hash once (which I would advise), though. Not sure about speeding up hashing vectorizer. You gotta ask @Larsmans and @ogrisel for that ;)

Having partial_fit on OneVsRestClassifier would be a nice addition, and I don't see a particular problem with it, actually. You could also try to implement that yourself and send a PR.

回答2:

1. The algorithm that OneVsRestClassifier implements is very simple: it just fits K binary classifiers when there are K classes. You can do this in your own code instead of relying on OneVsRestClassifier. You can also do this on at most K cores in parallel: just run K processes. If you have more classes than processors in your machine, you can schedule training with a tool such as GNU parallel.
2. Multi-core support in scikit-learn is work in progress; fine-grained parallel programming in Python is quite tricky. There are potential optimizations for HashingVectorizer, but I (one of the hashing code's authors) haven't come round to it yet.
3. If you follow my (and Andreas') advice to do your own one-vs-rest, this shouldn't be a problem anymore.
4. The trick in (1.) applies to any classification algorithm.

As for the number of features, it depends on the problem, but for large scale text classification 2^10 = 1024 seems very small. I'd try something around 2^18 - 2^22. If you train a model with L1 penalty, you can call sparsify on the trained model to convert its weight matrix to a more space-efficient format.

回答3:

My argument for scalability is that instead of using OneVsRest which is just a simplest of simplest baselines, you should use a more advanced ensemble of problem-transformation methods. In my paper I provide a scheme for dividing label space into subspaces and transforming the subproblems into multi-class single-label classifications using Label Powerset. To try this, just use the following code that utilizes a multi-label library built on top of scikit-learn - scikit-multilearn:

from skmultilearn.ensemble import LabelSpacePartitioningClassifier
from skmultilearn.cluster import IGraphLabelCooccurenceClusterer
from skmultilearn.problem_transform import LabelPowerset

from sklearn.linear_model import SGDClassifier

# base multi-class classifier SGD
base_classifier = SGDClassifier(loss='log', penalty='l2', n_jobs=-1)

# problem transformation from multi-label to single-label multi-class
transformation_classifier = LabelPowerset(base_classifier)

# clusterer dividing the label space using fast greedy modularity maximizing scheme
clusterer = IGraphLabelCooccurenceClusterer('fastgreedy', weighted=True, include_self_edges=True) 

# ensemble
clf = LabelSpacePartitioningClassifier(transformation_classifier, clusterer)

clf.fit(x_train, y_train)
prediction = clf.predict(x_test)

回答4:

The partial_fit() method was recently added to sklearn so hopefully it should be available in the upcoming release (it's in the master branch already).

The size of your problem makes it attractive to tackling it with neural networks. Have a look at magpie, it should give much better results than linear classifiers.

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/18684990/scalable-or-online-out-of-core-multi-label-classifiers