问题
How to match any character which repeats n
times?
Example:
for input: abcdbcdcdd
for n=1: ..........
for n=2: .........
for n=3: .. .....
for n=4: . . ..
for n=5: no matches
After several hours my best is this expression
(\w)(?=(?:.*\1){n-1,}) //where n is variable
which uses lookahead. However the problem with this expression is this:
for input: abcdbcdcdd
for n=1 ..........
for n=2 ... .. .
for n=3 .. .
for n=4 .
for n=5 no matches
As you can see, when lookahead matches for a character, let's look for n=4
line, d
's lookahead assertion satisfied and first d
matched by regex. But remaining d
's are not matched because they don't have 3 more d
's ahead of them.
I hope I stated the problem clearly. Hoping for your solutions, thanks in advance.
回答1:
let's look for n=4 line, d's lookahead assertion satisfied and first d matched by regex. But remaining d's are not matched because they don't have 3 more d's ahead of them.
And obviously, without regex, this is a very simple string manipulation problem. I'm trying to do this with and only with regex.
As with any regex implementation, the answer depends on the regex flavour. You could create a solution with .net regex engine, because it allows variable width lookbehinds.
Also, I'll provide a more generalized solution below for perl-compatible/like regex flavours.
.net Solution
As @PetSerAl pointed out in his answer, with variable width lookbehinds, we can assert back to the beggining of the string, and check there are n occurrences.
ideone demo
regex module in Python
You can implement this solution in python, using the regex module by Matthew Barnett, which also allows variable-width lookbehinds.
>>> import regex
>>> regex.findall( r'(\w)(?<=(?=(?>.*?\1){2})\A.*)', 'abcdbcdcdd')
['b', 'c', 'd', 'b', 'c', 'd', 'c', 'd', 'd']
>>> regex.findall( r'(\w)(?<=(?=(?>.*?\1){3})\A.*)', 'abcdbcdcdd')
['c', 'd', 'c', 'd', 'c', 'd', 'd']
>>> regex.findall( r'(\w)(?<=(?=(?>.*?\1){4})\A.*)', 'abcdbcdcdd')
['d', 'd', 'd', 'd']
>>> regex.findall( r'(\w)(?<=(?=(?>.*?\1){5})\A.*)', 'abcdbcdcdd')
[]
Generalized Solution
In pcre or any of the "perl-like" flavours, there is no solution that would actually return a match for every repeated character, but we could create one, and only one, capture for each character.
Strategy
For any given n, the logic involves:
- Early matches: Match and capture every character followed by at least n more occurences.
- Final captures:
- Match and capture a character followed by exactly n-1 occurences, and
- also capture every one of the following occurrences.
Example
for n = 3
input = abcdbcdcdd
The character c
is Matched only once (as final), and the following 2 occurrences are also Captured in the same match:
abcdbcdcdd
M C C
and the character d
is (early) Matched once:
abcdbcdcdd
M
and (finally) Matched one more time, Capturing the rest:
abcdbcdcdd
M CC
Regex
/(\w) # match 1 character
(?:
(?=(?:.*?\1){≪N≫}) # [1] followed by other ≪N≫ occurrences
| # OR
(?= # [2] followed by:
(?:(?!\1).)*(\1) # 2nd occurence <captured>
(?:(?!\1).)*(\1) # 3rd occurence <captured>
≪repeat previous≫ # repeat subpattern (n-1) times
# *exactly (n-1) times*
(?!.*?\1) # not followed by another occurence
)
)/xg
For n =
/(\w)(?:(?=(?:.*?\1){2})|(?=(?:(?!\1).)*(\1)(?!.*?\1)))/g
demo/(\w)(?:(?=(?:.*?\1){3})|(?=(?:(?!\1).)*(\1)(?:(?!\1).)*(\1)(?!.*?\1)))/g
demo/(\w)(?:(?=(?:.*?\1){4})|(?=(?:(?!\1).)*(\1)(?:(?!\1).)*(\1)(?:(?!\1).)*(\1)(?!.*?\1)))/g
demo- ... etc.
Pseudocode to generate the pattern
// Variables: N (int)
character = "(\w)"
early_match = "(?=(?:.*?\1){" + N + "})"
final_match = "(?="
for i = 1; i < N; i++
final_match += "(?:(?!\1).)*(\1)"
final_match += "(?!.*?\1))"
pattern = character + "(?:" + early_match + "|" + final_match + ")"
JavaScript Code
I'll show an implementation using javascript because we can check the result here (and if it works in javascript, it works in any perl-compatible regex flavour, including .net, java, python, ruby, perl, and all languages that implemented pcre, among others).
var str = 'abcdbcdcdd';
var pattern, re, match, N, i;
var output = "";
// We'll show the results for N = 2, 3 and 4
for (N = 2; N <= 4; N++) {
// Generate pattern
pattern = "(\\w)(?:(?=(?:.*?\\1){" + N + "})|(?=";
for (i = 1; i < N; i++) {
pattern += "(?:(?!\\1).)*(\\1)";
}
pattern += "(?!.*?\\1)))";
re = new RegExp(pattern, "g");
output += "<h3>N = " + N + "</h3><pre>Pattern: " + pattern + "\nText: " + str;
// Loop all matches
while ((match = re.exec(str)) !== null) {
output += "\nPos: " + match.index + "\tMatch:";
// Loop all captures
x = 1;
while (match[x] != null) {
output += " " + match[x];
x++;
}
}
output += "</pre>";
}
document.write(output);
Python3 code
As requested by the OP, I'm linking to a Python3 implementation in ideone.com
回答2:
Regular expressions (and finite automata) are not able to count to arbitrary integers. They can only count to a predefined integer and fortunately this is your case.
Solving this problem is much easier if we first construct a nondeterministic finite automata (NFA) ad then convert it to regular expression.
So the following automata for n=2 and input alphabet = {a,b,c,d}
will match any string that has exactly 2 repetitions of any char. If no character has 2 repetitions (all chars appear less or more that two times) the string will not match.
Converting it to regex should look like
"^([^a]*a[^a]*a[^a]*)|([^b]*b[^b]*b[^b]*)|([^b]*c[^c]*c[^C]*)|([^d]*d[^d]*d[^d]*)$"
This can get problematic if the input alphabet is big, so that regex should be shortened somehow, but I can't think of it right now.
回答3:
With .NET regular expressions you can do following:
(\w)(?<=(?=(?:.*\1){n})^.*) where n is variable
Where:
(\w)
— any character, captured in first group.(?<=^.*)
— lookbehind assertion, which return us to the start of the string.(?=(?:.*\1){n})
— lookahead assertion, to see if string haven
instances of that character.
Demo
回答4:
I would not use regular expressions for this. I would use a scripting language such as python. Try out this python function:
alpha = 'abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz'
def get_matched_chars(n, s):
s = s.lower()
return [char for char in alpha if s.count(char) == n]
The function will return a list of characters, all of which appear in the string s exactly n times. Keep in mind that I only included letters in my alphabet. You can change alpha to represent anything that you want to get matched.
来源:https://stackoverflow.com/questions/33181434/regex-matching-any-character-which-repeats-n-times