pydub append - clarification of under the hood behaviour

问题

I've been using pydub to concatenate short sound files into a larger sound file. The basic code for this looks like this:

def permuPhrase(iterations, joins): # Builds a single phrase and does various permutations of it
sampleSet = entryMatcher()
sampleSet.inputVars()
sampleSet.match()
concat = 0
if len(sampleSet.results) != 0:
    for x in range(iterations):
        for i in range(joins):
            rand = rn.randint(0, len(sampleSet.results)- 1)
            choice = str(sampleSet[rand])
            concat += (AudioSegment.from_wav(source+choice+affix))
        numIter = str(x) # convert parent for loop to string for naming .wav files.
        concat.export(newDir+numIter+affix, format="wav") # export
else:
    print("No samples matched")

My question is this. In the API it states there is by default an 100ms crossfade. However, the example given below suggests that if you use a + operator to concatenate samples it uses no crossfade. I was wondering if anyone can clarify this? I've linked the API as copying the example was not readable. It's under AudioSegment(...).append().

AudioSegment(…).append()

Returns a new AudioSegment, created by appending another AudioSegment to this one (i.e., adding it to the end), Optionally using a crossfade. AudioSegment(…).append() is used internally when adding AudioSegment objects together with the + operator.

By default a 100ms (0.1 second) crossfade is used to eliminate pops and crackles.

from pydub import AudioSegment
sound1 = AudioSegment.from_file("sound1.wav")
sound2 =AudioSegment.from_file("sound2.wav")

# default 100 ms crossfade
combined = sound1.append(sound2)

# 5000 ms crossfade
combined_with_5_sec_crossfade = sound1.append(sound2, crossfade=5000)

# no crossfade
no_crossfade1 = sound1.append(sound2, crossfade=0)

# no crossfade
no_crossfade2 = sound1 + sound2

Supported keyword arguments:

• crossfade | example: 3000 | default: 100 (entire duration of AudioSegment) When specified, method returns number of frames in X milliseconds of the AudioSegment

回答1:

I can confirm that concatenation using the + operator doesn’t apply any cross fade (and in fact calls the append method with crossfade=0)

The reason for that design decision was to allow using sum() and reduce() and other similar methods to put a bunch of chunks back together without altering the total duration (due to the crossfade overlaps)

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/50938152/pydub-append-clarification-of-under-the-hood-behaviour