问题
I'm building a RESTful API command to deactivate a user record. Is it kosher to use DELETE to do this or should this be a PUT, since the record is being updated to "deactivated" status? Or is it just a matter of taste?
回答1:
The semantics of DELETE
means that you are actually getting rid of the object. What you're doing here seems like a modification of the object's state. In this case a PUT
or PATCH
would be more appropriate.
It is better to stick with the semantics of uniform interface that you're using (in this case, HTTP verbs). If those match up to what you're actually doing within your app, then there is less confusion. Also, what if you decide later that a DELETE
should actually remove a record instead of just marking it "inactive"? Now you've changed the behavior of your API. Also, if you're using DELETE
, you're essentially following the "principle of least surprise", which is good for an API. It's better to have a DELETE
actually do a delete, rather than just pretending to do so.
On the other hand it is perfectly fine to remove the record from one location and move it elsewhere (from one table to another, for example) if it turns out that you are required to keep the data for historical purposes. In this case, that record should just remain unavailable to future operations (i.e., a GET
on the resource should return a 404
).
回答2:
If after your deactivation operation, the resource is not accessible to the end user any more through "GET" unless it is reactivated again, I do not see a problem using "DELETE". Otherwise, "PUT" is more appropriate.
回答3:
If the resource at the URL you send the DELETE
request to is no longer available at that URI, then DELETE
is appropriate. If it remains there but changes state, then it is not.
e.g. this is okay (the resource at /friends/bob goes away; a new resource is created at /formerfriends/bob in the process, but that is incidental):
GET /friends/bob => 200 OK
GET /formerfriends/bob => 404 Not Found
DELETE /friends/bob => 204 No Content
GET /friends/bob => 410 Gone
GET /formerfriends/bob => 200 OK
this is not:
GET /friends/bob => 200 OK {"status"="friend"}
DELETE /friends/bob => 204 No Content
GET /friends/bob => 200 OK {"status"="formerfriend"}
something like that would be better handled with PUT
or PATCH
:
GET /friends/bob => 200 OK {"status"="friend"}
PATCH /friends/bob {"status"="formerfriend"} => 204 No Content
GET /friends/bob => 200 OK {"status"="formerfriend"}
来源:https://stackoverflow.com/questions/15205938/is-it-okay-to-use-an-http-delete-to-deactivate-a-record