最近在做蓝牙开发,研究了一下蓝牙的启动流程,总结一下
Google在Android源码中推出了它和博通公司一起开发的BlueDroid以替代BlueZ。BlueZ的创始者,高通公司也将在基于其芯片的Android参考设计中去除BlueZ,支持BlueDroid。相比BlueZ,BlueDroid最值得称道的地方就是其框架结构变得更为简洁和清晰。对我们工程师来说这也是个不错的福利,清晰、简洁的架构使我们在debug过程中思路更清晰;
蓝牙的总体流程图
从流程图我们可以看出来 蓝牙应用通过binder和系统蓝牙Service进行通讯 ,然后通过Jin与蓝牙HAL层进行通讯.
按层级划分
Bluetooth Service(Java层)代码路径
frameworks/base/core/java/Android/Bluetooth:
Bluetooth 应用层代码路径
packages/apps/Bluetooth
Bluetooth协议层代码
system/bt/
涉及的总共路径:
frameworks/base/core/java/android/bluetooth/BluetoothAdapter.java
frameworks/base/core/java/android/bluetooth/BluetoothManagerService.java
packages/apps/Bluetooth/src/com/android/bluetooth/btservice/AdapterService.java
packages/apps/Bluetooth/src/com/android/bluetooth/btservice/AdapterState.java
packages/apps/Bluetooth/jni/com_android_bluetooth_btservice_AdapterService.cpp
system/bt/btif/src/btif_dm.c
system/bt/btif/include/btif_common.h
hardware/libhardware/include/hardware/bluetooth.h
一.将蓝牙作为sink模式 配置
sink模式一般是车机端需要设置的模式,用于链接手机之后可以播放蓝牙音乐,获取联系人,和电话控制等等
packages/apps/Bluetooth/src/com/android/bluetooth/btservice/Config.java
有如下两个参数控制是否是 sink端
boolean isA2dpSinkEnabled = SystemProperties.getBoolean("persist.service.bt.a2dp.sink", false);
boolean isHfpClientEnabled = SystemProperties.getBoolean("persist.service.bt.hfp.client",false);
我们需要在编译源码的时候去配置成sink模式
device/qcom/msmxxx_64/system.prop
添加如下配置
persist.service.bt.a2dp.sink=true
persist.service.bt.hfp.client=true
再具体的配置信息在如下配置中进行设置具体支持那种profile
packages/apps/Bluetooth/res/values/config.xml
<resources>
<bool name="profile_supported_a2dp">true</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_a2dp_sink">false</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_hdp">true</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_hs_hfp">true</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_hfpclient">false</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_hid">true</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_opp">true</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_pan">true</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_pbap">true</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_gatt">true</bool>
<bool name="pbap_include_photos_in_vcard">true</bool>
<bool name="pbap_use_profile_for_owner_vcard">true</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_map">true</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_avrcp_controller">false</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_sap">false</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_pbapclient">false</bool>
<bool name="strict_location_check">true</bool>
</resources>
当然修改上面的配置我们可以在如下路径配置
vendor/qcom/opensource/bluetooth/res/values/config.xml
<resources>
<bool name="profile_supported_ftp">true</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_map">false</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_sap">true</bool>
<bool name="profile_supported_dun">true</bool>
</resources>
如果 packages/apps/Bluetooth/res/values/config.xml 和 vendor/qcom/opensource/bluetooth/res/values/config.xml 都配置了如下配置 或者是配置的两个Boolean 值是反向的,系统会依据 vendor/qcom/opensource/bluetooth/res/values/config.xml 配置为最终结果,配置完成之后编译系统,烧录系统就可以作为sink端使用,也就是接收端.
二.启动流程分析
首先我们调用蓝牙的时候使用的是Bluetooth的 BluetoothAdapter.java 类 中的enable方法
路径如下
frameworks/base/core/java/android/bluetooth/BluetoothAdapter.java
public boolean enable() {
android.util.SeempLog.record(56);
if (isEnabled()) {
if (DBG) Log.d(TAG, "enable(): BT already enabled!");
return true;
}
try {
// 此处调用的是 IBluetoothManager.java的 enable
return mManagerService.enable(ActivityThread.currentPackageName());
} catch (RemoteException e) {Log.e(TAG, "", e);}
return false;
}
我们查看到 IBluetoothManager.java的实现类是BluetoothManagerService.java , BluetoothManagerService.java
class BluetoothManagerService extends IBluetoothManager.Stub {
.....省略代码.....
public boolean enable(String packageName) throws RemoteException {
final int callingUid = Binder.getCallingUid();
final boolean callerSystem = UserHandle.getAppId(callingUid) == Process.SYSTEM_UID;
.....省略代码.....
// 权限检查
.....省略代码.....
synchronized(mReceiver) {
mQuietEnableExternal = false;
mEnableExternal = true;
// waive WRITE_SECURE_SETTINGS permission check
sendEnableMsg(false, packageName);
}
if (DBG) Slog.d(TAG, "enable returning");
return true;
}
.....省略代码.....
}
我们继续查看可以看到调用的是 sendEnableMsg(boolean quietMode, String packageName) 方法.
private void sendEnableMsg(boolean quietMode, String packageName) {
mHandler.sendMessage(mHandler.obtainMessage(MESSAGE_ENABLE,
quietMode ? 1 : 0, 0));
addActiveLog(packageName, true);
}
在sendEnableMsg 方法中 发送了一个message消息 MESSAGE_ENABLE
case MESSAGE_ENABLE:
try {
if (mBluetooth != null) {
int state = mBluetooth.getState();
if (state == BluetoothAdapter.STATE_BLE_ON) {
//如果蓝牙已经打开调用 BluetoothAdapterService.java 开启profile
mBluetooth.onLeServiceUp();
//保存蓝牙的开关状态
persistBluetoothSetting(BLUETOOTH_ON_BLUETOOTH);
break;
}
}
}
mQuietEnable = (msg.arg1 == 1);
//如果没有蓝牙没有打开去打开蓝牙
if (mBluetooth == null) {
handleEnable(mQuietEnable);
} else {
if(state == BluetoothAdapter.STATE_TURNING_OFF || state == BluetoothAdapter.STATE_BLE_TURNING_OFF)
waitForMonitoredOnOff(false, true);
//重启蓝牙
Message restartMsg = mHandler.obtainMessage(
MESSAGE_RESTART_BLUETOOTH_SERVICE);
mHandler.sendMessageDelayed(restartMsg,
2 * SERVICE_RESTART_TIME_MS);
}
break;
在 MESSAGE_ENABLE 接收的消息中会先判断盘牙是否打开,如果已经打开 就调用mBluetooth.onLeServiceUp();去打开 Profile文件如果没有打开就调用handleEnable(mQuietEnable);去打开蓝牙. 咱们这里先不看 mBluetooth.onLeServiceUp(); 方法先查看handleEnable(mQuietEnable)
private void handleEnable(boolean quietMode) {
if ((mBluetooth == null) && (!mBinding)) {
//蓝牙打开超时记录
Message timeoutMsg=mHandler.obtainMessage(MESSAGE_TIMEOUT_BIND);
mHandler.sendMessageDelayed(timeoutMsg,TIMEOUT_BIND_MS);
Intent i = new Intent(IBluetooth.class.getName());
//此处我们查看到 mConnection 方法是链接状态的回调
if (!doBind(i, mConnection,Context.BIND_AUTO_CREATE | Context.BIND_IMPORTANT,
UserHandle.CURRENT)) {
mHandler.removeMessages(MESSAGE_TIMEOUT_BIND);
} else {
mBinding = true;
}
}
}
其中mConnection 是链接的回调 BluetoothServiceConnection 就是 mConnection 类
在BluetoothServiceConnection 类中会发送 MESSAGE_BLUETOOTH_SERVICE_CONNECTED 消息并传递了一个 AdapterService对象.
private class BluetoothServiceConnection implements ServiceConnection {
public void onServiceConnected(ComponentName componentName, IBinder service) {
String name = componentName.getClassName();
if (DBG) Slog.d(TAG, "BluetoothServiceConnection: " + name);
Message msg = mHandler.obtainMessage(MESSAGE_BLUETOOTH_SERVICE_CONNECTED);
if (name.equals("com.android.bluetooth.btservice.AdapterService")) {
msg.arg1 = SERVICE_IBLUETOOTH;
}
msg.obj = service;
mHandler.sendMessage(msg);
}
public void onServiceDisconnected(ComponentName componentName) {
// Called if we unexpectedly disconnect.
String name = componentName.getClassName();
if (DBG) Slog.d(TAG, "BluetoothServiceConnection, disconnected: " + name);
Message msg = mHandler.obtainMessage(MESSAGE_BLUETOOTH_SERVICE_DISCONNECTED);
if (name.equals("com.android.bluetooth.btservice.AdapterService")) {
msg.arg1 = SERVICE_IBLUETOOTH;
}
mHandler.sendMessage(msg);
}
}
我们继续追踪 MESSAGE_BLUETOOTH_SERVICE_CONNECTED消息
case MESSAGE_BLUETOOTH_SERVICE_CONNECTED:
{
IBinder service = (IBinder) msg.obj;
mBinding = false;
mBluetoothBinder = service;
mBluetooth = IBluetooth.Stub.asInterface(service);
//注册 CallBack 重要,后面的回调要使用
try {
mBluetooth.registerCallback(mBluetoothCallback);
} catch (RemoteException re) {
Slog.e(TAG, "Unable to register BluetoothCallback",re);
}
//Do enable request
try {
//打开蓝牙请求
if (mQuietEnable == false) {
if (!mBluetooth.enable()) {
Slog.e(TAG,"IBluetooth.enable() returned false");
}
}
}
break;
}
MESSAGE_BLUETOOTH_SERVICE_CONNECTED消息里面可以查看到 mBluetooth = IBluetooth.Stub.asInterface(service);获取的是 IBluetooth 对象 , 而AdapterService.java 内部类 AdapterServiceBinder 实现了 IBluetooth
packages/apps/Bluetooth/src/com/android/bluetooth/btservice/AdapterService.java
private static class AdapterServiceBinder extends IBluetooth.Stub {
private AdapterService mService;
public AdapterService getService() {
if (mService != null && mService.isAvailable()) {
return mService;
}
return null;
}
public boolean enable() {
........
AdapterService service = getService();
if (service == null) return false;
return service.enable();
}
}
由上面可以看出 return service.enable();调用的是 AdapterService.java 中的方法 enable() 方法
public synchronized boolean enable(boolean quietMode) {
enforceCallingOrSelfPermission(BLUETOOTH_ADMIN_PERM, "Need BLUETOOTH ADMIN permission");
debugLog("enable() - Enable called with quiet mode status = " + mQuietmode);
mQuietmode = quietMode;
Message m = mAdapterStateMachine.obtainMessage(AdapterState.BLE_TURN_ON);
mAdapterStateMachine.sendMessage(m);
mBluetoothStartTime = System.currentTimeMillis();
return true;
}
发送的是 BLE_TURN_ON
packages/apps/Bluetooth/src/com/android/bluetooth/btservice/AdapterState.java 接受了这个消息
case BLE_TURN_ON:
notifyAdapterStateChange(BluetoothAdapter.STATE_BLE_TURNING_ON);
//将蓝牙的状态转换成 mPendingCommandState
mPendingCommandState.setBleTurningOn(true);
transitionTo(mPendingCommandState);
sendMessageDelayed(BLE_START_TIMEOUT, BLE_START_TIMEOUT_DELAY);
adapterService.BleOnProcessStart();
break;
将了蓝牙的状态转换成 mPendingCommandState 调用 BleOnProcessStart 方法,也可以在supportedProfileServices 方法中去掉自己不想开启的ProfileService.
void BleOnProcessStart() {
//获取支持的profile 文件
Class[] supportedProfileServices = Config.getSupportedProfiles();
//Initialize data objects
for (int i=0; i < supportedProfileServices.length;i++) {
mProfileServicesState.put(supportedProfileServices[i].getName(),BluetoothAdapter.STATE_OFF);
}
mRemoteDevices.cleanup();
mAdapterProperties.init(mRemoteDevices);
mJniCallbacks.init(mBondStateMachine,mRemoteDevices);
//Start Gatt service
//调用 ProfileService
setGattProfileServiceState(supportedProfileServices,BluetoothAdapter.STATE_ON);
}
获取支持的ProfileService列表.
private static final Class[] PROFILE_SERVICES = {
HeadsetService.class,
A2dpService.class,
A2dpSinkService.class,
HidService.class,
HealthService.class,
PanService.class,
GattService.class,
BluetoothMapService.class,
HeadsetClientService.class,
AvrcpControllerService.class,
SapService.class,
PbapClientService.class
};
//发送 ACTION_SERVICE_STATE_CHANGED参数 每一个profile 都有 遍历开启 profile
private void setGattProfileServiceState(Class[] services, int state) {
for (int i=0; i <services.length;i++) {
mProfileServicesState.put(serviceName,pendingState);
Intent intent = new Intent(this,services[i]);
intent.putExtra(EXTRA_ACTION,ACTION_SERVICE_STATE_CHANGED);
intent.putExtra(BluetoothAdapter.EXTRA_STATE,state);
startService(intent);
return;
}
}
}
public int onStartCommand(Intent intent, int flags, int startId) {
if (intent == null) {
Log.d(mName, "Restarting profile service...");
return PROFILE_SERVICE_MODE;
} else {
String action = intent.getStringExtra(AdapterService.EXTRA_ACTION);
if (AdapterService.ACTION_SERVICE_STATE_CHANGED.equals(action)) {
} else if (state == BluetoothAdapter.STATE_ON) {
........省略代码......
// 开启服务
doStart(intent);
}
}
return PROFILE_SERVICE_MODE;
}
调用doStartService之后 我们可以看到调用了 notifyProfileServiceStateChanged 方法。
private void doStart(Intent intent) {
if (!mStartError) {
// 开始调用 notifyProfileServiceStateChanged
notifyProfileServiceStateChanged(BluetoothAdapter.STATE_ON);
}
}
继续查看notifyProfileServiceStateChanged 方法 ,里面又回到了AdapterServer 中的 onProfileServiceStateChanged方法
protected void notifyProfileServiceStateChanged(int state) {
//Notify adapter service
AdapterService adapterService = AdapterService.getAdapterService();
if (adapterService != null) {
adapterService.onProfileServiceStateChanged(getClass().getName(), state);
}
}
发送MESSAGE_PROFILE_SERVICE_STATE_CHANGED 消息 给消息处理
public void onProfileServiceStateChanged(String serviceName, int state) {
Message m = mHandler.obtainMessage(MESSAGE_PROFILE_SERVICE_STATE_CHANGED);
m.obj=serviceName;
m.arg1 = state;
mHandler.sendMessage(m);
}
在消息接收的地方查看到蓝牙的 processProfileServiceStateChanged 方法被调用,在processProfileServiceStateChanged 方法中发送了 BLE_STARTED 消息,而这个消息接受的地方是开起底层ProfileService的地方。
case MESSAGE_PROFILE_SERVICE_STATE_CHANGED: {
debugLog("handleMessage() - MESSAGE_PROFILE_SERVICE_STATE_CHANGED");
processProfileServiceStateChanged((String) msg.obj, msg.arg1);
}
break;
private void processProfileServiceStateChanged(String serviceName, int state) {
if (isBleTurningOn) {
if (serviceName.equals("com.android.bluetooth.gatt.GattService")) {
debugLog("GattService is started");
mAdapterStateMachine.sendMessage(mAdapterStateMachine.obtainMessage(AdapterState.BLE_STARTED));
return;
}
}
}
/packages/apps/Bluetooth/src/com/android/bluetooth/btservice/AdapterState.java BLE_STARTED消息处理任务,通过 adapterService.enableNative(isGuest) 开启底层的profileService。
case BLE_STARTED:
//开启底层服务
if (!adapterService.enableNative(isGuest)) {
errorLog("Error while turning Bluetooth on");
notifyAdapterStateChange(BluetoothAdapter.STATE_OFF);
transitionTo(mOffState);
}
break;
调用的是 AdapterService.java 中的native方法 ,根据包名和JNI 方法的名称我们可以推算出来调用的CPP的名称是 com_android_bluetooth_btservice_AdapterService.cpp
/*package*/ native boolean enableNative(boolean startRestricted);
在如下路径找到了 packages/apps/Bluetooth/jni/com_android_bluetooth_btservice_AdapterService.cpp 在enableNative中查看到 int ret = sBluetoothInterface->enable(isGuest == JNI_TRUE ? 1 : 0); 调用的是 sBluetoothInterface 中的enable方法
static jboolean enableNative(JNIEnv* env, jobject obj, jboolean isGuest) {
ALOGV("%s:",__FUNCTION__);
jboolean result = JNI_FALSE;
if (!sBluetoothInterface) return result;
int ret = sBluetoothInterface->enable(isGuest == JNI_TRUE ? 1 : 0);
result = (ret == BT_STATUS_SUCCESS || ret == BT_STATUS_DONE) ? JNI_TRUE : JNI_FALSE;
return result;
}
具体的实现在 bluetooth.c中。
/system/bt/btif/src/bluetooth.c
static int enable(bool start_restricted) {
LOG_INFO(LOG_TAG, "%s: start restricted = %d", __func__, start_restricted);
restricted_mode = start_restricted;
if (!interface_ready())
return BT_STATUS_NOT_READY;
stack_manager_get_interface()->start_up_stack_async();
return BT_STATUS_SUCCESS;
}
底层回调传递到上层的时候主要使用的是 btif_dm.c 中对消息的处理 BTA_DM_INQ_RES_EVT 消息
system/bt/btif/src/btif_dm.c
static void btif_dm_search_devices_evt (UINT16 event, char *p_param)
{
...省略代码.....
case BTA_DM_INQ_RES_EVT:
...省略代码.....
/* Callback to notify upper layer of device */
HAL_CBACK(bt_hal_cbacks, device_found_cb,
num_properties, properties);
break;
/system/bt/btif/include/btif_common.h
define HAL_CBACK(P_CB, P_CBACK, ...) 方法 , HAL_CBACK就是一宏定义,就是调用结构体中对应的方法
extern bt_callbacks_t *bt_hal_cbacks;
#define HAL_CBACK(P_CB, P_CBACK, ...)\
if (P_CB && P_CB->P_CBACK) { \
BTIF_TRACE_API("HAL %s->%s", #P_CB, #P_CBACK); \
P_CB->P_CBACK(__VA_ARGS__); \
} \
else { \
ASSERTC(0, "Callback is NULL", 0); \
}
bt_hal_cbacks 其实就是 蓝牙AdapterService中调用了initNative方法传入到底层的。看下jni中的initNative方法:
@Override
public void onCreate() {
super.onCreate();
..........
//调用底层方法
initNative();
........
}
private native boolean initNative();
调用com_android_bluetooth_btservice_AdapterService.cpp init方法 将Callback传递到底层
static bool initNative(JNIEnv* env, jobject obj) {
.......
//调用com_android_bluetooth_btservice_AdapterService.cpp init方法 将Callback传递到底层
// 再调用 bluetooth.c 的 init方法
int ret = sBluetoothInterface->init(&sBluetoothCallbacks);
.......
}
com_android_bluetooth_btservice_AdapterService.cpp 再调用 bluetooth.c 的 init方法
static int init(bt_callbacks_t *callbacks) {
CallBack传递到底层
bt_hal_cbacks = callbacks;
stack_manager_get_interface()->init_stack();
}
其实这里有两个地方有 bt_callbacks_t 我们可以对比看一下
1./hardware/libhardware/include/hardware/bluetooth.h
2. /packages/apps/Bluetooth/jni/com_android_bluetooth_btservice_AdapterService.cpp
bluetooth.h 中的 bt_callbacks_t
typedef struct {
/** set to sizeof(bt_callbacks_t) */
size_t size;
adapter_state_changed_callback adapter_state_changed_cb;
adapter_properties_callback adapter_properties_cb;
remote_device_properties_callback remote_device_properties_cb;
device_found_callback device_found_cb;
discovery_state_changed_callback discovery_state_changed_cb;
pin_request_callback pin_request_cb;
ssp_request_callback ssp_request_cb;
bond_state_changed_callback bond_state_changed_cb;
acl_state_changed_callback acl_state_changed_cb;
callback_thread_event thread_evt_cb;
dut_mode_recv_callback dut_mode_recv_cb;
le_test_mode_callback le_test_mode_cb;
energy_info_callback energy_info_cb;
} bt_callbacks_t;
// com_android_bluetooth_btservice_AdapterService.cpp 中的 bt_callbacks_t
static bt_callbacks_t sBluetoothCallbacks = {
sizeof(sBluetoothCallbacks),
adapter_state_change_callback,
adapter_properties_callback,
remote_device_properties_callback,
device_found_callback,
discovery_state_changed_callback,
pin_request_callback,
ssp_request_callback,
bond_state_changed_callback,
acl_state_changed_callback,
callback_thread_event,
dut_mode_recv_callback,
le_test_mode_recv_callback,
energy_info_recv_callback
};
static bt_callbacks_t sBluetoothCallbacks = {
sizeof(sBluetoothCallbacks),
adapter_state_change_callback,
adapter_properties_callback,
remote_device_properties_callback,
device_found_callback,
discovery_state_changed_callback,
pin_request_callback,
ssp_request_callback,
bond_state_changed_callback,
acl_state_changed_callback,
callback_thread_event,
dut_mode_recv_callback,
le_test_mode_recv_callback,
energy_info_recv_callback
};
最后蓝牙驱动打开之后会通过
/system/bt/btif/src/btif_core.c 中的 btif_enable_bluetooth_evt(tBTA_STATUS status) 回调给应用
void btif_enable_bluetooth_evt(tBTA_STATUS status){
// 省略代码
HAL_CBACK(bt_hal_cbacks, adapter_properties_cb, BT_STATUS_SUCCESS, 1, &prop);
}
然后回调给 adapter_properties_callback:返回手机蓝牙设备的地址、名称、UUID
adapter_state_change_callback 回调 通过 C调用 Java的代码 callbackEnv->CallVoidMethod(sJniCallbacksObj, method_stateChangeCallback, (jint)status); 返回给应用中的也就是回调java层代码 JniCallback.java文件中stateChangeCallback方法。这时跳转到AdapterState.java中,执行stateChangeCallback()方法;发送了ENABLED_READY消息。根据以上分析,这时状态机还处于PendingCommandState,在该状态下处理ENABLED_READY消息,
case ENABLED_READY:
removeMessages(ENABLE_TIMEOUT);
mPendingCommandState.setBleTurningOn(false);
transitionTo(mBleOnState);
notifyAdapterStateChange(BluetoothAdapter.STATE_BLE_ON);
break;
做下面两个动作:状态切换到mOnState;更新adapterProperties中的蓝牙状态信息;通知蓝牙状态变为打开。具体看下notifyAdapterStateChange方法。主要是调用了adapterService类的方法。
private void notifyAdapterStateChange(int newState) {
AdapterService adapterService = mAdapterService;
AdapterProperties adapterProperties = mAdapterProperties;
if ((adapterService == null) || (adapterProperties == null)) {
errorLog("notifyAdapterStateChange after cleanup:" + newState);
return;
}
int oldState = adapterProperties.getState();
adapterProperties.setState(newState);
infoLog("Bluetooth adapter state changed: " + oldState + "-> " + newState);
adapterService.updateAdapterState(oldState, newState);
}
adapterService.updateAdapterState(oldState, newState);
来到adapterService类。
void updateAdapterState(int prevState, int newState){
if (mCallbacks !=null) {
int n=mCallbacks.beginBroadcast();
debugLog("updateAdapterState() - Broadcasting state to " + n + " receivers.");
for (int i=0; i <n;i++) {
try {
// 完成回调 发送广播给调用者
mCallbacks.getBroadcastItem(i).onBluetoothStateChange(prevState,newState);
} catch (RemoteException e) {
debugLog("updateAdapterState() - Callback #" + i + " failed (" + e + ")");
}
}
mCallbacks.finishBroadcast();
}
}
之前在打开蓝牙操作初期,在BluetoothManagerService中注册了回调方法,因此又跳转到framework中,执行回调方法。蓝牙打开从framework公共接口开始调用enable方法,执行到bluetooth.apk中,在该应用中通过jni注册回调方法和调用hal层打开蓝牙方法,在驱动层完成蓝牙上电等操作后,通过hal-jni回调到应用层中,应用通过aidl回调通知framework蓝牙状态变化,framework发送广播通知大家蓝牙打开。
来源:oschina
链接:https://my.oschina.net/u/4344814/blog/4539396