Defining an Abstract model with a ForeignKey to another Abstract model

问题

I'm trying to build two abstract classes called SurveyQuestionBase and SurveyResponseBase that will serve as templates to quickly define new concrete Models for implementing specific surveys on our website. The issue I am having is in enforcing that the SurveyResponseBase model, when made concrete, should define a ForeignKey to a concrete model of SurveyQuestionBase.

Django does not allow us to define ForeignKeys to abstract classes so I cannot, for instance, do this: question = models.ForeignKey(SurveyQuestionBase) Neither can I have it as None or app_label.ModelName for similar reasons.

One hacky fix is to create a new concrete model SurveyQuestionConcrete and make the ForeignKey point to this: question = models.ForeignKey(concrete_model), combined with validation to ensure this model is replaced.

Is there a cleaner way to achieve the same thing? All I need to do is ensure that when someone defines a concrete model from SurveyResponseBase they include a ForeignKey to a concrete model defined from SurveyQuestionBase

Here's the full code:

from __future__ import unicode_literals


from django.contrib.contenttypes.fields import GenericForeignKey
from django.contrib.contenttypes.models import ContentType
from django.db import models

# Implementation borrows from: https://github.com/jessykate/django-survey/


class SurveyQuestionBase(models.Model):
    TEXT = 'text'
    INTEGER = 'integer'
    RADIO = 'radio'
    SELECT = 'select'
    MULTI_SELECT = 'multi-select'

    ANSWER_TYPE_CHOICES = (
        (INTEGER, 'Integer',),
        (TEXT, 'Text',),
        (RADIO, 'Radio',),
        (SELECT, 'Select',),
        (MULTI_SELECT, 'Multi-Select',),
    )

    question = models.TextField()
    required = models.BooleanField()
    question_type = models.CharField(choices=ANSWER_TYPE_CHOICES, max_length=20)

    class Meta:
        abstract = True


class SurveyResponseBase(models.Model):
    """
    concrete_question_model: 'app_label.Model' - Define the concrete model this question belongs to
    """
    concrete_model = 'SurveyQuestionBase'

    question = models.ForeignKey(concrete_model)
    response = models.TextField()

    class Meta:
        abstract = True

回答1:

Two solutions (both working) to this problem:

The first solution involves using GenericForeignKey. The second is more interesting and involves generating the SurveyResponseBase dynamically.

Solution 1: Using GenericForeignKey

class SurveyQuestionBase(models.Model):
    TEXT = 'text'
    INTEGER = 'integer'
    RADIO = 'radio'
    SELECT = 'select'
    MULTI_SELECT = 'multi-select'

    ANSWER_TYPE_CHOICES = (
        (INTEGER, 'Integer',),
        (TEXT, 'Text',),
        (RADIO, 'Radio',),
        (SELECT, 'Select',),
        (MULTI_SELECT, 'Multi-Select',),
    )

    question = models.TextField()
    required = models.BooleanField()
    question_type = models.CharField(choices=ANSWER_TYPE_CHOICES, max_length=20)

    class Meta:
        abstract = True

    @classmethod
    def get_subclasses(cls, *args, **kwargs):
        for app_config in apps.get_app_configs():
            for app_model in app_config.get_models():
                model_classes = [c.__name__ for c in inspect.getmro(app_model)]
                if cls.__name__ in model_classes:
                    yield app_model


class SurveyResponseBase(models.Model):
    content_type = models.ForeignKey(ContentType, on_delete=models.CASCADE, limit_choices_to=get_content_choices)
    object_id = models.PositiveIntegerField()
    content_object = GenericForeignKey('content_type', 'object_id')
    response = models.TextField()

    class Meta:
        abstract = True

def get_content_choices():
    query_filter = None

    for cls in SurveyQuestionBase.get_subclasses():
        app_label, model = cls._meta.label_lower.split('.')
        current_filter = models.Q(app_label=app_label, model=model)

        if query_filter is None:
            query_filter = current_filter
        else:
            query_filter |= current_filter

    return query_filter

Solution 2: Dynamic base class generation

class SurveyQuestionBase(models.Model):
    TEXT = 'text'
    INTEGER = 'integer'
    RADIO = 'radio'
    RATING = 'rating'
    SELECT = 'select'
    MULTI_SELECT = 'multi-select'

    QUESTION_TYPES = (
        (INTEGER, 'Integer'),
        (TEXT, 'Text'),
        (RADIO, 'Radio'),
        (RATING, 'Rating'),
        (SELECT, 'Select'),
        (MULTI_SELECT, 'Multi-Select'),
    )

    CHOICE_TYPES = (RADIO, RATING, SELECT, MULTI_SELECT)

    question = models.TextField()
    required = models.BooleanField()
    question_type = models.CharField(choices=QUESTION_TYPES, max_length=20)
    choices = models.TextField(blank=True, null=True)

    choices.help_text = """
    If the question type is "Radio," "Select," or "Multi-Select", 
    provide a comma-separated list of options for this question
    """

    class Meta:
        abstract = True


Meta = type('Meta', (object,), {'abstract': True})


def get_response_base_class(concrete_question_model):
    """
    Builder method that returns the SurveyResponseBase base class
    Args:
        concrete_question_model: Concrete Model for SurveyQuestionBase

    Returns: SurveyResponseBase Class
    """
    try:
        assert SurveyQuestionBase in concrete_question_model.__bases__
    except AssertionError:
        raise ValidationError('{} is not a subclass of SurveyQuestionBase'.format(concrete_question_model))

    attrs = {
        'question': models.ForeignKey(concrete_question_model, related_name='responses'),
        'response': models.TextField(),
        '__module__': 'survey_builder.models',
        'Meta': Meta(),
    }
    return type('SurveyResponseBase', (models.Model,), attrs)

We decided to go ahead with Solution 2 since the GenericForeignKeys approach requires an additional ContentType selection.

回答2:

I believe you can't do that because the ForeignKey doesn't know what actual model to point to.

You may be looking for GenericForeignKey (https://docs.djangoproject.com/en/dev/ref/contrib/contenttypes/#generic-relations). It allows you to define that relationship properly.

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/44965172/defining-an-abstract-model-with-a-foreignkey-to-another-abstract-model