setuid on an executable doesn't seem to work

问题

I wrote a small C utility called killSPR to kill the following processes on my RHEL box. The idea is for anyone who logs into this linux box to be able to use this utility to kill the below mentioned processes (which doesn't work - explained below).

cadmn@rhel /tmp > ps -eaf | grep -v grep | grep " SPR "  
cadmn    5822  5821 99 17:19 ?        00:33:13 SPR 4 cadmn  
cadmn   10466 10465 99 17:25 ?        00:26:34 SPR 4 cadmn  
cadmn   13431 13430 99 17:32 ?        00:19:55 SPR 4 cadmn  
cadmn   17320 17319 99 17:39 ?        00:13:04 SPR 4 cadmn  
cadmn   20589 20588 99 16:50 ?        01:01:30 SPR 4 cadmn  
cadmn   22084 22083 99 17:45 ?        00:06:34 SPR 4 cadmn  
cadmn@rhel /tmp >

This utility is owned by the user cadmn (under which these processes run) and has the setuid flag set on it (shown below).

cadmn@rhel /tmp > ls -l killSPR  
-rwsr-xr-x 1 cadmn cusers 9925 Dec 17 17:51 killSPR  
cadmn@rhel /tmp >

The C code is given below:

/*  
 * Program Name: killSPR.c  
 * Description: A simple program that kills all SPR processes that  
 * run as user cadmn  
 */  
#include <stdio.h>  
int main()  
{  
    char *input;  
    printf("Before you proceed, find out under which ID I'm running. Hit enter when you are done...");  
    fgets(input, 2, stdin);  

    const char *killCmd = "kill -9 $(ps -eaf | grep -v grep | grep \" SPR \" | awk '{print $2}')";  
    system(killCmd);  
    return 0;  
}

A user (pmn) different from cadmn tries to kill the above-mentioned processes with this utility and fails (shown below):

pmn@rhel /tmp > ./killSPR  
Before you proceed, find out under which ID I'm running. Hit enter when you are done...  
sh: line 0: kill: (5822) - Operation not permitted  
sh: line 0: kill: (10466) - Operation not permitted  
sh: line 0: kill: (13431) - Operation not permitted  
sh: line 0: kill: (17320) - Operation not permitted  
sh: line 0: kill: (20589) - Operation not permitted  
sh: line 0: kill: (22084) - Operation not permitted  
pmn@rhel /tmp >

While the user waits to hit enter above, the process killSPR is inspected and is seen to be running as the user cadmn (shown below) despite which killSPR is unable to terminate the processes.

cadmn@rhel /tmp > ps -eaf | grep -v grep | grep killSPR  
cadmn   24851 22918  0 17:51 pts/36   00:00:00 ./killSPR  
cadmn@rhel /tmp >

BTW, none of the main partitions have any nosuid on them

pmn@rhel /tmp > mount | grep nosuid
pmn@rhel /tmp >

The setuid flag on the executable doesn't seem to have the desired effect. What am I missing here? Have I misunderstood how setuid works?

回答1:

First and foremost, setuid bit simply allows a script to set the uid. The script still needs to call setuid() or setreuid() to run in the the real uid or effective uid respectively. Without calling setuid() or setreuid(), the script will still run as the user who invoked the script.

Avoid system and exec as they drop privileges for security reason. You can use kill() to kill the processes.

Check These out.

http://linux.die.net/man/2/setuid

http://man7.org/linux/man-pages/man2/setreuid.2.html

http://man7.org/linux/man-pages/man2/kill.2.html

回答2:

You should replace your system call with exec call. Manual for system say's it drops privileges when run from suid program.

The reason is explained in man system:

Do not use system() from a program with set-user-ID or set-group-ID privileges, because strange values for some environment variables might be used to subvert system integrity. Use the exec(3) family of func‐ tions instead, but not execlp(3) or execvp(3). system() will not, in fact, work properly from programs with set-user-ID or set-group-ID privileges on systems on which /bin/sh is bash version 2, since bash 2 drops privileges on startup. (Debian uses a modified bash which does not do this when invoked as sh.)

If you replace system with exec you will need to be able to use shell syntax unless you call /bin/sh -c <shell command>, this is what is system actually doing.

回答3:

Check out this link on making a shell script a daemon:

Best way to make a shell script daemon?

You might also want to google some 'linux script to service', I found a couple of links on this subject.

The idea is that you wrap a shell script that has some basic stuff in it that allows a user to control a program run as another user by calling a 'service' type script instead. For example, you could wrap up /usr/var/myservice/SPRkiller as a 'service' script that could then just be called as such from any user: service SPRkiller start, then SPRkiller would run, kill the appropriate services (assuming the SPR 'program' is run as a non-root user).

This is what it sounds like you are trying to achieve. Running a program (shell script/C program/whatever) carries the same user restrictions on it no matter what (except for escalation bugs/hacks).

On a side note, you seem to have a slight misunderstanding of user rights on Linux/Unix as well as what certain commands and functions do. If a user does not have permissions to do a certain action (like kill the process of another user), then calling setuid on the program you want to kill (or on kill itself) will have no effect because the user does not have permission to another users 'space' without super user rights. So even if you're in a shell script or a C program and called the same system command, you will get the same effect.

http://www.linux.com/learn/ is a great resource, and here's a link for file permissions

hope that helps

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/20684607/setuid-on-an-executable-doesnt-seem-to-work

标签

Linux

process

setuid