Unit/Integration tests for DAL and BLL (with lambdas)

问题

My code basically looks like this:

Data access contract:

public interface IProvideDataAccess<T>
    where T : Entity
{
    IEnumerable<T> Select(Func<T, bool> condition);
    void Save(T entity);
    void Delete(T entity);
}

Data access layer:

public class Db4oProvider<T> : IProvideDataAccess<T>
    where T : Entity
{
    private IEmbeddedConfiguration _configuration;
    private string _connectionString;

    public Db4oAccesDonnees(string connectionString)
    {
        _connectionString = connectionString;
        _configuration = Db4oEmbedded.NewConfiguration();
    }

    IEnumerable<T> IProvideDataAccess<T>.Select(Func<T, bool> condition)
    {
        using (IObjectContainer db = Db4oEmbedded.OpenFile(_configuration, _connexion))
        {
            return db.Query<T>(e => condition(e));
        }
    }
    void IProvideDataAccess<T>.Save(T entity)
    {
        using (IObjectContainer db = Db4oEmbedded.OpenFile(_configuration, _connexion))
        {
            db.Store(entity);
        }
    }
    void IProvideDataAccess<T>.Delete(T entity)
    {
        using (IObjectContainer db = Db4oEmbedded.OpenFile(_configuration, _connexion))
        {
            db.Delete(entity);
        }
    }
}

Business logic layer:

public class MyRepository
{
    protected IProvideDataAccess<MyEntityType> _dataAccessProvider;

    public MyRepository(IProvideDataAccess<MyEntityType> dataAccessProvider)
    {
        _dataAccessProvider = dataAccessProvider;
    }

    public IEnumerable<MyEntityType> SelectValidEntities()
    {
        return _dataAccessProvider.Select(e => /* test if entity is valid */);
    }
}

Unit/Integration tests are fairly new to me and I'm not sure where to begin.

I think the logical thing to do would be to

write integration tests for the DAL
write unit tests for the BLL (with fake DAL)

I this correct?

My biggest problem is with the "select" method and its Func parameter. How do I test/mock that?

Basically, what tests should I write for these two classes?

回答1:

Your DAL looks like the classes which never change... In my opinion creating a UT or IT on them is a waste of time. You should cover class's behavior like Db4oProvider<T> with a good Component/"large Integration"(not only the unit + DB) tests. I offer you to read about Test Pyramid(In Martin Fowler blog and this good article). I like the following pyramid:

About the Select method:

In Integration test(unit + DB) you have to put data inside your DB(or keep a DB with data...), call Select with a condition, then verify that you've got the expected data.

In Component test you need to test it as a part of behavior under test, if the test succeed then every thing is alright...

In UT the tests are split into 2 types:

1.The tests where you verify the behaviour of the condition(lambda) you pass into Select method:(in this way you also verify that Select was called with the right parameters... In my examples I use RhinoMocks)

var fakeProvider = MockRepository.GenerateStub<IProvideDataAccess<Entity>>();

fakeProvider.Select(o => o.Id =="asdfg");

fakeProvider.AssertWasCalled(access => access.Select(Arg<Func<Entity, bool>>
            .Matches(func => func(new Entity()
            {
                Id = "asdfg"
            }))));

2.The tests where you verify caller method behaviour. In those tests you should configure your DAL to return something matter the parameters are:

_selectResult = new List<Entity>();
fakeProvider.Stub(x => x.Select(Arg<Func<Entity, bool>>.Is.Anything))
            .Return(_selectResult);

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/32013575/unit-integration-tests-for-dal-and-bll-with-lambdas

标签

unit-testing

mocking

integration-testing

data-access-layer