问题
I made a script that opens a xls. file, writes a few new value's in it, then save the file.
Later the script opens it again, and wants to find the answers in some cells which contain formulas.
If I call that cell with openpyxl, I get the formula (ie: =A1*B1). And if I activate data_only, i get nothing.
Is there a way to let python calculate the xls file? (or should I try PyXll?)
回答1:
There is actually a project that takes Excel formulas and evaluates them using Python: Pycel. Pycel uses Excel itself (via COM) to extract the formulas, so in your case you would skip that part. The project probably has something useful that you can use, but I can't vouch for its maturity or completeness. It was not really developed for the general public.
There is also a newer project called Koala which builds on both Pycel and OpenPyXL.
Another approach, if you can't use Excel but you can calculate the results of the formulas yourself (in your Python code), is to write both the value and the formula into a cell (so that when you read the file, you can just pull the value, and not worry about the formula at all). As of this writing, I haven't found a way to do it in OpenPyXL, but XlsxWriter can do it. From the documentation:
XlsxWriter doesn’t calculate the value of a formula and instead stores the value 0 as the formula result. It then sets a global flag in the XLSX file to say that all formulas and functions should be recalculated when the file is opened. This is the method recommended in the Excel documentation and in general it works fine with spreadsheet applications. However, applications that don’t have a facility to calculate formulas, such as Excel Viewer, or some mobile applications will only display the 0 results.
If required, it is also possible to specify the calculated result of the formula using the options value parameter. This is occasionally necessary when working with non-Excel applications that don’t calculate the value of the formula. The calculated value is added at the end of the argument list:
worksheet.write_formula('A1', '=2+2', num_format, 4)
With this approach, when it's time to read the value, you would use OpenPyXL's data_only option. (For other people reading this answer: If you use xlrd, then only the value is available anyway.)
Finally, if you do have Excel, then perhaps the most straightforward and reliable thing you can do is automate the opening and resaving of your file in Excel (so that it will calculate and write the values of the formulas for you). xlwings is an easy way to do this from either Windows or Mac.
回答2:
I realize this question is old, but I ran into the same problem and extensive searching didn't produce an answer.
The solution is in fact quite simple so I will post it here for posterity.
Let's assume you have an xlsx file that you have modified with openpyxl. As Charlie Clark mentioned openpyxl will not calculate the formulas, but if you were to open the file in excel the formulas would be automatically calculated. So all you need to do is open the file and then save it using excel.
To do this you can use the win32com module.
import win32com.client as win32
excel = win32.gencache.EnsureDispatch('Excel.Application')
workbook = excel.Workbooks.Open(r'absolute/path/to/your/file')
# this must be the absolute path (r'C:/abc/def/ghi')
workbook.Save()
workbook.Close()
excel.Quit()
That's it. I've seen all these suggestions to use Pycel or Koala, but that seems like a bit of overkill if all you need to do is tell excel to open and save.
Granted this solution is only for windows.
回答3:
No, and in openpyxl there will never be. I think there is a Python library that purports to implements an engine for such formualae which you can use.
回答4:
I run into the same problem, and after some time researching I ended up using pyoo ( https://pypi.org/project/pyoo/ ) which is for openoffice/libreoffice so available in all platforms and is more straightforward since communicates natively and doesn't require to save/close the file . I tried several other libraries but found the following problems
- xlswings: Only works if you have Excel installed and Windows/MacOS so I couldn't evaluate
- koala : Seems that it's broken, after networkx 2.4 update.
- openpyxl: As pointed out by others, it isn't able to calculate formulas so I was looking into combining it with pycel to get values. I didn 't finally tried because I found pyoo . Openpyxl+pycel might not work as of now, since pycel is also relying on networkx library.
回答5:
The formula module works for me. For detail please refer to https://pypi.org/project/formulas/
from openpyxl import load_workbook
import formulas
#The variable spreadsheet provides the full path with filename to the excel spreadsheet with unevaluated formulae
fpath = path.basename(spreadsheet)
dirname = path.dirname(spreadsheet)
xl_model = formulas.ExcelModel().loads(fpath).finish()
xl_model.calculate()
xl_model.write(dirpath=dirname)
#Use openpyxl to open the updated excel spreadsheet now
wb = load_workbook(filename=spreadsheet,data_only=True)
ws = wb.active
来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/22451973/calculating-excel-sheets-without-opening-them-openpyxl-or-xlwt