Custom memory allocator for real-mode DOS .COM (freestanding) — how to debug?

问题

A little background first: stumbling upon this blog post, I learned it was possible to create DOS .COM files with the GNU linker and it's not even rocket science. Using clang and the -m16 switch (creating real-mode compatible 32bit code by prefixing 32bit instructions accordingly), this worked out quite well. So I had the idea to try implementing just enough runtime to get a little curses game I wrote recently to compile to a .COM and run in real-mode DOS. The game is small enough so that squeezing everything (text, data, bss, heap, stack) in 64KB seemed doable. Of course, it uses malloc(). So I had to come up with my own implementation. This is what it looks like:

typedef unsigned short size_t; /* from stddef.h */

typedef struct hhdr hhdr;
struct hhdr
{
    void *next;
    int free;
};

extern char _heap;
static char *hbreak = &_heap;
static hhdr hhead = { &_heap, 0 };

static void *newchunk(size_t size)
{
    char *stack;
    __asm__("mov %%esp, %0": "=rm" (stack));
    if (hbreak + size > stack - 0x40) return 0;
    if (size < 1024) size = 1024;
    hhdr *chunk = (hhdr *)hbreak;
    hbreak += size;
    if (hbreak > stack - 0x40) hbreak = stack - 0x40;
    chunk->next = hbreak;
    chunk->free = 1;
    return chunk;
}

void *malloc(size_t size)
{
    if (!size) return 0;
    if (size % sizeof(hhdr)) size += sizeof(hhdr) - (size % sizeof(hhdr));

    hhdr *hdr = &hhead;
    while ((char *)hdr->next < hbreak)
    {
        hdr = hdr->next;
        if (hdr->free && 
                (char *)hdr->next - (char *)hdr - sizeof(hhdr) >= size)
        {
            if ((char *)hdr->next - (char *)hdr - 2*sizeof(hhdr) > size)
            {
                hhdr *hdr2 = (hhdr *)((char *)hdr + sizeof(hhdr) + size);
                hdr2->free = 1;
                hdr2->next = hdr->next;
                hdr->next = hdr2;
            }
            hdr->free = 0;
            return (char *)hdr + sizeof(hhdr);
        }
    }

    if (!(hdr->next = newchunk(size + sizeof(hhdr)))) return 0;
    return malloc(size);
}

void free(void *ptr)
{
    if (!ptr) return;
    hhdr *hdr = (hhdr *)((char *)ptr - sizeof(hhdr));
    hdr->free = 1;
    if ((void *)hdr != hhead.next)
    {
        hhdr *hdr2 = hhead.next;
        while (hdr2->next != hdr) hdr2 = hdr2->next;
        if (hdr2->free) hdr = hdr2;
    }
    hhdr *next = hdr->next;
    while ((char *)next < hbreak)
    {
        if (!next->free) break;
        hdr->next = next;
        next = next->next;
    }
    if ((char *)next == hbreak) hbreak = (char *)hdr;
}

The _heap symbol is defined by the linker. Not showing realloc() here as it isn't used right now anyways (and therefore completely untested).

The problem now is: I created my runtime here (malloc is in src/libdos/stdlib.c), wrote a lot of testing stuff and in the end, everything seemed to work quite well. My game on the other hand is thoroughly tested and checked for invalid memory accesses using valgrind. Still, putting both parts together, it just crashes. (Try building the game from git with make -f libdos.mk, you will need to have llvm/clang installed).

As I experienced a strange heisenbug first (I worked around it for now), I guess it COULD be the optimizers fault getting things wrong when compiling for real mode, which is indeed uncommon. But I can't be sure, and the next sensitive candidate would be probably my memory management, see above.

Now the tricky question: How would I debug such a thing? With just my own test code, it works very well. I can't compile my game without optimizations because it will exceed 64KB when doing so. Any suggestions? Or can anyone spot something obviously wrong with the above code?

回答1:

If this is real mode DOS, I'm not sure about the upper bits of esp. As for malloc(), use the memory between ss:sp and 0xa000:0000, the memory between the top of the stack and the 640k boundary . I don't recall if MS-DOS allocates all of the 640k region for a .COM program or not. There are two DOS calls, INT 21H, ah = 04Ah releases memory, ah = 048H allocates memory, but I don't recall if these are for .COM or .EXE programs.

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/31842228/custom-memory-allocator-for-real-mode-dos-com-freestanding-how-to-debug

标签

memory-management

dos

freestanding