问题
I've been enjoying a hefty process creation penalty on my Windows XP Home SP3 for about two months. The problem is most manifest and annoying with tasks that do create lots of processes, such as shell scripts (incidentally, bash scripts on Cygwin), Makefiles, or unpacking an IzPack package such as the SpringSource Tool Suite installer (lots of separate unpack200.exe JAR extractor processes). I'm sure it's process creation from observing bash script diagnostic output, or watching processes appear in task manager. There is no noticeable delay once a process is up and running.
I've reported that problem on the Cygwin mailing list as I initially and erroneously thought only Cygwin was affected, suspecting a bug in the Cygwin DLL, or whatnot.
Slowdown after update on Win32 (XP Home) - (link to my post to the Cygwin list)
I'm wondering whether something has installed some crap into a process creation hook which I presume might exist on Windows. (As with the security manager in Java.) A virus, or security software? I haven't consciously installed either. I also suspected a Microsoft update glitch, but I think they would have fixed that by now.
As far as I know, processes on Win32 are created by CreateProcess.
How can I find out why process creation takes so long and what exactly is going on here? Is there something like strace for Linux, or possibly even something better?
回答1:
Many thanks to Luke for pointing me in the right direction. Procmon is a fantastic tool. Literally, a new world inside the system opened up for me. And the culprit was quickly found by setting a filter to include parent process ID = WINPID of a Cygwin bash.exe and then just monitoring a single ls command. It was malware hooked into a registry key named AppCertDlls, of which I was of course totally unaware before.
Once I moved the malware clipmote.dll out of system32, process creation speed was immediately back to normal.
I guess I contracted this virus by installing poisoned freeware.
I spent some time investigating this issue and found it both scary and interesting, so here's what I've found, and of course I'll be thankful for all additional information or any comments you might have.
The malware DLL was loaded in every single user process, even Explorer, taskmgr, and procmon itself. Only processes under SYSTEM (as listed in in procexp.exe) appear to have remained uninfected.
The issue here is that HKLM\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Control\Session Manager\AppCertDlls is checked (at least on my system, but possibly on many systems, and probably even by default) to load DLLs which may have a say over whether or not some binary is allowed to run or not by returning a value from a function that is called on them:
NTSTATUS STDCALL CreateProcessNotify (LPCWSTR lpApplicationName, ULONG Reason);
In fact, I had an entry under that key called sethdown, but the name could be anything.
RegEnumValue HKLM\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Control\Session Manager\AppCertDlls
Index: 0
Name: sethdown
Type: REG_SZ
Length: 66
Data: C:\WINDOWS\system32\clipmote.dll
From reports found on the net I conclude that the AppCertDlls hook is a regular part of the Windows operating system, and not some rogue extension. If that is so, it's a virus entry point, as it allows to dynamically configure malware into a process.
Looks like it is actually - and ironically - meant to be a security feature, not dissimilar to the security manger in the JVM (see my original question). A Microsoft utility called appsec.exe is reported to use this key. The function that is then called on the "security" DLL that is loaded is CreateProcessNotify, as quoted above. From what I've understood, it is assumed to just say yes or no - but it can do whatever it wants.
In my case and the single instance of running ls.exe that I analysed, it created five threads. They load or try to load other DLLs and interact with the registry. And who knows what else.
If anyone knows more about this dangerous mechanism, I'm all ears.
Here's what I found on AppCertDlls:
early mention in 01/2007 (Re5: Блокировка запуска приложений)
AppCertDlls reported on Sysinternals forum (Autoruns), 10/2007
About AppCertDlls - virus mentioned 01/2008
But Microsoft itself widely use this feature, exactly, it was in fact conceived as the "one-time" thing. Only for use it as - way to limit the applications that can be run under the terminal server 2000. -- Andrew Worobow
more details on the AppCertDlls key and CreateProcessNotify, 01/2008
06/2010 infection report providing some details
The malware tried to steal bank account information (and money, obviously), but it could possibly be configured to do other things, too. There were additional registry entries under HKEY_CURRENT_USER\Software\AppDataLow\{some GUID here}. It must have done some screen scraping while I was doing online banking; it knew used TANs. I remember I once I had the impression my bank was hacked when shortly before or (probably) after login I saw a screen asking for about twenty TANs at once. WTF, I thought, the browser got the wrong URL, and I closed the window. I should have be more concerned. I wouldn't have thought the whole issue to be so dangerous. Fortunately, no damage. Just lucky, I guess.
Here's a list of the significant-looking strings I found inside the virus:
client.dllEAPSFILT.dllKERNEL32.dll
I think the first two might be other virus libraries it tries to load.
_aullshrCompareStringACreateEventACreateFileACreateFileMappingACreateProcessNotifyCtfImmIsCiceroStartedInThreadCtfImmTIMActivateDllCleanupServerDllStartupServerExitProcessGetThreadContextImmDisableImeImmDisableIMEImmGetConversionListAImmGetVirtualKeyImmRegisterWordAImmSetCandidateWindowInterlockedExchangeAddiswlowerlstrcmpAMapViewOfFilememsetOpenThreadReadFileRealDriveTypeRegenerateUserEnvironmentRestartDialogSetFilePointerSleepstrchrTerminateThreadUnmapViewOfFilevDbgPrintExWithPrefixVirtualQueryExWaitForMultipleObjects
The Cicero function looked rogue to me, but it is part of C:\WINDOWS\system32\imm32.dll, the "Windows IMM32 API Client Library" - whatever that is.
I ran sfc.exe, Microsoft's "System File Checker". Will do more checking on my program files. And get a virus scanner. Recommendations welcome.
来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/4354445/appcertdlls-process-creation-slowdown-on-win32-caused-by-virus