问题
I am new to C programming. I used to think using exit() was the cleanest way of process termination (as it is capable of removing temporary files, closing open files, normal process termination...), but when I tried man exit command on the terminal (Ubuntu 16.04.5, gcc 5.4.0) I saw the following line:
The exit() function uses a global variable that is not protected, so it is not thread-safe.
After that I tried to make some research about better replacement for exit() (to change my programming behavior from the beginning). While doing that I faced with this question in which side effects of exit() is mentioned and it is suggested to use atexit() properly to solve the problem (at least partially).
There were some cases in which using abort() was preferred over exit(). On top of that, this question suggests that atexit() might also be harmful.
So here are my questions:
- Is there any general and better way of process terminating (which is guaranteed to clean like
exit()and is not harmful for the system at any case)? - If the answer to the first question is NO!, what is the best possible way of process terminating (including the cases in which they are most useful)?
回答1:
what is the best possible way of process terminating
- If going single threaded just use
exit(), as your code is not going multi-threaded. - Else make sure all but one thread have ended before the last thread and then safely call
exit()because of 1. above.
回答2:
Given that power/hardware fails can happen at any time, the imposs.. extreme difficulty of reliably terminating threads with user code and the chaotic nature of the use of memory pools etc. in many non-trivial multithreaded apps, it is better to design apps and systems that can clean temp files etc. on start-up, rather than trying to micro-manage shutdown.
'Clean up all the resources you allocate before you exit' sounds like good advice in a classroom or lecture, but quickly becomes a whole chain of albatross round your neck when faced with a dozen threads, queues and pools in a continually changing dynamic system.
If you can, if you are running under a non trivial OS, let it do its job and clean up for you. It's much better at it than your user code will ever be.
来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/55063381/better-replacement-for-exit-atexit-in-c