问题
I have a WPF application with two PasswordBoxes, one for the password and another for the password to be entered a second time for confirmation purposes. I was wanting to use PasswordBox.SecurePassword to get the SecureString of the password, but I need to be able to compare the contents of the two PasswordBoxes to ensure equality before I accept the password. However, two identical SecureStrings are not considered equal:
var secString1 = new SecureString();
var secString2 = new SecureString();
foreach (char c in "testing")
{
secString1.AppendChar(c);
secString2.AppendChar(c);
}
Assert.AreEqual(secString1, secString2); // This fails
I was thinking comparing the Password property of the PasswordBoxes would defeat the point of accessing only SecurePassword because I'd be reading the plain-text password. What should I do to compare the two passwords without sacrificing security?
Edit: based on this question, I'm checking out this blog post about "using the Marshal class to convert the SecureString to ANSI or Unicode or a BSTR", then maybe I can compare those.
回答1:
It looks like you could use this to compare the two SecureStrings.
It uses unsafe code to iterate through the strings:
bool SecureStringEqual(SecureString s1, SecureString s2)
{
if (s1 == null)
{
throw new ArgumentNullException("s1");
}
if (s2 == null)
{
throw new ArgumentNullException("s2");
}
if (s1.Length != s2.Length)
{
return false;
}
IntPtr bstr1 = IntPtr.Zero;
IntPtr bstr2 = IntPtr.Zero;
RuntimeHelpers.PrepareConstrainedRegions();
try
{
bstr1 = Marshal.SecureStringToBSTR(s1);
bstr2 = Marshal.SecureStringToBSTR(s2);
unsafe
{
for (Char* ptr1 = (Char*)bstr1.ToPointer(), ptr2 = (Char*)bstr2.ToPointer();
*ptr1 != 0 && *ptr2 != 0;
++ptr1, ++ptr2)
{
if (*ptr1 != *ptr2)
{
return false;
}
}
}
return true;
}
finally
{
if (bstr1 != IntPtr.Zero)
{
Marshal.ZeroFreeBSTR(bstr1);
}
if (bstr2 != IntPtr.Zero)
{
Marshal.ZeroFreeBSTR(bstr2);
}
}
}
I have modified it below to work without unsafe code (note however you are able to see the string in plain text when debugging):
Boolean SecureStringEqual(SecureString secureString1, SecureString secureString2)
{
if (secureString1 == null)
{
throw new ArgumentNullException("s1");
}
if (secureString2 == null)
{
throw new ArgumentNullException("s2");
}
if (secureString1.Length != secureString2.Length)
{
return false;
}
IntPtr ss_bstr1_ptr = IntPtr.Zero;
IntPtr ss_bstr2_ptr = IntPtr.Zero;
try
{
ss_bstr1_ptr = Marshal.SecureStringToBSTR(secureString1);
ss_bstr2_ptr = Marshal.SecureStringToBSTR(secureString2);
String str1 = Marshal.PtrToStringBSTR(ss_bstr1_ptr);
String str2 = Marshal.PtrToStringBSTR(ss_bstr2_ptr);
return str1.Equals(str2);
}
finally
{
if (ss_bstr1_ptr != IntPtr.Zero)
{
Marshal.ZeroFreeBSTR(ss_bstr1_ptr);
}
if (ss_bstr2_ptr != IntPtr.Zero)
{
Marshal.ZeroFreeBSTR(ss_bstr2_ptr);
}
}
}
回答2:
This doesn't have unsafe blocks and won't display the password in plaintext:
public static bool IsEqualTo(this SecureString ss1, SecureString ss2)
{
IntPtr bstr1 = IntPtr.Zero;
IntPtr bstr2 = IntPtr.Zero;
try
{
bstr1 = Marshal.SecureStringToBSTR(ss1);
bstr2 = Marshal.SecureStringToBSTR(ss2);
int length1 = Marshal.ReadInt32(bstr1, -4);
int length2 = Marshal.ReadInt32(bstr2, -4);
if (length1 == length2)
{
for (int x = 0; x < length1; ++x)
{
byte b1 = Marshal.ReadByte(bstr1, x);
byte b2 = Marshal.ReadByte(bstr2, x);
if (b1 != b2) return false;
}
}
else return false;
return true;
}
finally
{
if (bstr2 != IntPtr.Zero) Marshal.ZeroFreeBSTR(bstr2);
if (bstr1 != IntPtr.Zero) Marshal.ZeroFreeBSTR(bstr1);
}
}
Edit: Fixed the leak as recommended by Alex J.
回答3:
Translating @NikolaNovák answer to plain PowerShell:
param(
[Parameter(mandatory=$true,position=0)][SecureString]$ss1,
[Parameter(mandatory=$true,position=1)][SecureString]$ss2
)
function IsEqualTo{
param(
[Parameter(mandatory=$true,position=0)][SecureString]$ss1,
[Parameter(mandatory=$true,position=1)][SecureString]$ss2
)
begin{
[IntPtr] $bstr1 = [IntPtr]::Zero;
[IntPtr] $bstr2 = [IntPtr]::Zero;
[bool]$answer=$true;
}
process{
try{
$bstr1 = [System.Runtime.InteropServices.Marshal]::SecureStringToBSTR($ss1);
$bstr2 = [System.Runtime.InteropServices.Marshal]::SecureStringToBSTR($ss2);
[int]$length1 = [System.Runtime.InteropServices.Marshal]::ReadInt32($bstr1, -4);
[int]$length2 = [System.Runtime.InteropServices.Marshal]::ReadInt32($bstr2, -4);
if ($length1 -eq $length2){
for ([int]$x -eq 0; $x -lt $length1; ++$x){
[byte]$b1 = [System.Runtime.InteropServices.Marshal]::ReadByte($bstr1, $x);
[byte]$b2 = [System.Runtime.InteropServices.Marshal]::ReadByte($bstr2, $x);
if ($b1 -ne $b2){
$answer=$false;
}
}
}
else{ $answer=$false;}
}
catch{
}
finally
{
if ($bstr2 -ne [IntPtr]::Zero){ [System.Runtime.InteropServices.Marshal]::ZeroFreeBSTR($bstr2)};
if ($bstr1 -ne [IntPtr]::Zero){ [System.Runtime.InteropServices.Marshal]::ZeroFreeBSTR($bstr1)};
}
}
END{
return $answer
}
}
IsEqualTo -ss1 $ss1 -ss2 $ss2
回答4:
You could take a different approach. I hit the same problem in my code, the comparison of a password and a confirmation, both of type SecureString. I realised that the end goal was that the new password needs to be stored in the database as a base-64 string. So what I did was simply pass the confirmation string through the same code as if I were going to write it to the database. Then, when I have two base-64 strings, I compare them at that point, which is a simple string comparison.
It does take a bit more plumbing to communicate any failure all the way back to the UI layer, but the end result seemed acceptable. This code hopefully is enough to give the basic idea.
private string CalculateHash( SecureString securePasswordString, string saltString )
{
IntPtr unmanagedString = IntPtr.Zero;
try
{
unmanagedString = Marshal.SecureStringToGlobalAllocUnicode( securePasswordString );
byte[] passwordBytes = Encoding.UTF8.GetBytes( Marshal.PtrToStringUni( unmanagedString ) );
byte[] saltBytes = Encoding.UTF8.GetBytes( saltString );
byte[] passwordPlusSaltBytes = new byte[ passwordBytes.Length + saltBytes.Length ];
Buffer.BlockCopy( passwordBytes, 0, passwordPlusSaltBytes, 0, passwordBytes.Length );
Buffer.BlockCopy( saltBytes, 0, passwordPlusSaltBytes, passwordBytes.Length, saltBytes.Length );
HashAlgorithm algorithm = new SHA256Managed();
return Convert.ToBase64String( algorithm.ComputeHash( passwordPlusSaltBytes ) );
}
finally
{
if( unmanagedString != IntPtr.Zero )
Marshal.ZeroFreeGlobalAllocUnicode( unmanagedString );
}
}
string passwordSalt = "INSERT YOUR CHOSEN METHOD FOR CONSTRUCTING A PASSWORD SALT HERE";
string passwordHashed = CalculateHash( securePasswordString, passwordSalt );
string confirmPasswordHashed = CalculateHash( secureConfirmPasswordString, passwordSalt );
if( passwordHashed == confirmPasswordHashed )
{
// Both matched so go ahead and persist the new password.
}
else
{
// Strings don't match, so communicate the failure back to the UI.
}
I am a bit of a newbie at security programming, so I welcome any suggestions for improvement.
回答5:
If the code is running on Windows Vista or higher, here is a version that's based on the CompareStringOrdinal Windows function, so there's no plain text, all buffers stay unmanaged. Bonus is it supports case-insensitive comparison.
public static bool EqualsOrdinal(this SecureString text1, SecureString text2, bool ignoreCase = false)
{
if (text1 == text2)
return true;
if (text1 == null)
return text2 == null;
if (text2 == null)
return false;
if (text1.Length != text2.Length)
return false;
var b1 = IntPtr.Zero;
var b2 = IntPtr.Zero;
try
{
b1 = Marshal.SecureStringToBSTR(text1);
b2 = Marshal.SecureStringToBSTR(text2);
return CompareStringOrdinal(b1, text1.Length, b2, text2.Length, ignoreCase) == CSTR_EQUAL;
}
finally
{
if (b1 != IntPtr.Zero)
{
Marshal.ZeroFreeBSTR(b1);
}
if (b2 != IntPtr.Zero)
{
Marshal.ZeroFreeBSTR(b2);
}
}
}
public static bool EqualsOrdinal(this SecureString text1, string text2, bool ignoreCase = false)
{
if (text1 == null)
return text2 == null;
if (text2 == null)
return false;
if (text1.Length != text2.Length)
return false;
var b = IntPtr.Zero;
try
{
b = Marshal.SecureStringToBSTR(text1);
return CompareStringOrdinal(b, text1.Length, text2, text2.Length, ignoreCase) == CSTR_EQUAL;
}
finally
{
if (b != IntPtr.Zero)
{
Marshal.ZeroFreeBSTR(b);
}
}
}
private const int CSTR_EQUAL = 2;
[DllImport("kernel32")]
private static extern int CompareStringOrdinal(IntPtr lpString1, int cchCount1, IntPtr lpString2, int cchCount2, bool bIgnoreCase);
[DllImport("kernel32")]
private static extern int CompareStringOrdinal(IntPtr lpString1, int cchCount1, [MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.LPWStr)] string lpString2, int cchCount2, bool bIgnoreCase);
来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/4502676/c-sharp-compare-two-securestrings-for-equality