How to decide between _init and _create in jQuery UI widget?

Question

I think I understand the difference between _create and _init in widget definitions (see for instance this question), but I\'m still not certain about

Answer 1

Short answer here: _create() will be executed when you run your jquery-ui plugin for the first time, like $xx.your-plugin(your options); _init() will be executed first and after the first time when your code runs into $xx.your-plugin(your options);

As there are some code in jquery-ui.custom.js like this:

var instance = $.data( this, fullName );
if ( instance ) {
    instance.option( options || {} )._init();
}

So, if you draw a chart with jquery-ui plugin, after it's drawn out, then you want to use new data to update it, you need to do this in _init() to update your chart. If you just display something and won't update them totally, _create() will meet your needs.

Answer 2

From:

• http://forum.jquery.com/topic/jquery-ui-1-8-use-of-init
• http://www.erichynds.com/jquery/tips-for-developing-jquery-ui-widgets/
• http://jqueryui.com/demos/dialog/

Use _create to build and inject markup, bind events, etc. Place default functionality in _init(). The dialog widget, for example, provides an autoOpen parameter denoting whether or not the dialog should be open once the widget is initialized; a perfect spot for _init()!

Also:

The widget factory automatically fires the _create() and _init() methods during initialization, in that order. At first glance it appears that the effort is duplicated, but there is a sight difference between the two. Because the widget factory protects against multiple instantiations on the same element, _create() will be called a maximum of one time for each widget instance, whereas _init() will be called each time the widget is called without arguments...

If the author uses _init() when _create() should have been coded, the result will be that the code in _init() will be executed once per widget instantiation.