Different behaviour of comma operator in C++ with return?

Question

This (note the comma operator):

#include 
int main() {
    int x;
    x = 2, 3;
    std::cout << x << \"\\n\";
    r         


        

Answer 1

According to the Operator Precedence, comma operator has lower precedence than operator=, so x = 2,3; is equivalent to (x = 2),3;. (Operator precedence determines how operator will be bound to its arguments, tighter or looser than other operators according to their precedences.)

Note the comma expression is (x = 2),3 here, not 2,3. x = 2 is evaluated at first (and its side effects are completed), then the result is discarded, then 3 is evaluated (it does nothing in fact). That's why the value of x is 2. Note that 3 is the result of the whole comma expression (i.e. x = 2,3), it won't be used to assign to x. (Change it to x = (2,3);, x will be assigned with 3.)

For return 2,3;, the comma expression is 2,3, 2 is evaluated then its result is discarded, and then 3 is evaluated and returned as the result of the whole comma expression, which is returned by the return statement later.

---

Additional informations about Expressions and Statements

An expression is a sequence of operators and their operands, that specifies a computation.

x = 2,3; is expression statement, x = 2,3 is the expression here.

An expression followed by a semicolon is a statement.

Syntax: attr(optional) expression(optional) ; (1)

return 2,3; is jump statement (return statement), 2,3 is the expression here.

Syntax: attr(optional) return expression(optional) ; (1)

Answer 2

This statement:

  x = 2,3;

is composed by two expressions:

> x = 2
> 3

Since operator precedence, = has more precedence than comma ,, so x = 2 is evaluated and after 3. Then x will be equal to 2.

---

In the return instead:

int f(){ return 2,3; }

The language syntax is :

return <expression>

Note return is not part of expression.

So in that case the two expression will be evaluated will be:

> 2
> 3

But only the second (3) will be returned.

Answer 3

Try to apply the simplistic approach just highlighting the precedence with parenthesis:

( x = 2 ), 3;

return ( 2, 3 );

Now we can see the binary operator "," working in the same way on both, from left to right.

Answer 4

The comma (also known as the expression separation) operator is evaluated from left to right. So return 2,3; is equivalent to return 3;.

The evaluation of x = 2,3; is (x = 2), 3; due to operator precedence. Evaluation is still from left to right, and the entire expression has the value 3 with the side-effect of x assuming the value of 2.