How to use MATLAB code in mapper (Hadoop)?

Question

I have a matlab code that processes images. I want to create a Hadoop mapper that uses that code. I came across the following solutions but not sure which one is best (as it is

Answer 1

Does not the nature of the algorithm to be converted matter? If the MATLAB/Octave code is tightly coupled, spreading it out over a map-reduced may yield horrible behavior.

Answer 2

With respect to your first option: The Matlab Coder now supports many image processing functions (partly via system objects) to automatically generate C-code of your algorithm, which is basically platform independent and needs no runtime environment. From my experience this code is about a factor 2..3 slower than "hand-coded" OpenCV (strongly depends on your algorithm and cpu). The main drawback is, you need a Matlab Coder license ($$$).

Answer 3

As you are probably already suspecting, this is going to be inherently difficult to do because of the runtime requirement for MATLAB. I had a similar experience (having to distribute the runtime libraries) when attempting to run MATLAB code over Condor.

As far as the options you are listing are concerned, option #1 will work best. Also, you will probably not be available to avoid working with Linux.

However, if you don't want to lose the convenience provided by higher level software (such as MATLAB, Octave, Scilab and others) you could try Hadoop streaming in combination with Octave executable scripts.

Hadoop streaming does not care about the nature of the executable (whether it is an executable script or an executable file, according to this (http://hadoop.apache.org/common/docs/r0.15.2/streaming.html)).

All it requires, is that it is given an "executable" that in addition can a) read from stdin, b) send output to stdout.

GNU Octave programs can be turned into executable scripts (in Linux) with the ability to read from stdin and send the output to stdout (http://www.gnu.org/software/octave/doc/interpreter/Executable-Octave-Programs.html).

As a simple example consider this:

Create a file (for example "al.oct") with the following contents:

#!/bin/octave -qf  (Please note, in my installation i had to use "#!/etc/alternatives/octave -qf")
Q = fread(stdin); #Standard Octave / MATLAB code from here on
disp(Q);

Now from the command prompt issue the following command:

chmod +x al.oct

al.oct is now an executable...You can execute it with "./al.oct". To see where the stdin,stdout fits in (so that you can use it with Hadoop) you can try this:

>>cat al.oct|./al.oct|sort

Or in other words..."cat" the file al.oct, pipe its output to the executable script al.oct and then pipe the output of al.oct to the sort utility (this is just an example,we could have "cat" any file, but since we know that al.oct is a simple text file we just use this).

It could be of course that Octave does not support everything your MATLAB code is trying to call, but this could be an alternative way to using Hadoop Streaming without losing the convenience / power of higher level code.

Answer 4

Most of the answers here seem to be pre MATLAB R2014b.

In R2014b, MATLAB allows mapreduce from within MATLAB and integration with Hadoop.

I cannot be certain about your specific use case but you may want to check:

http://www.mathworks.com/help/matlab/mapreduce.html

http://www.mathworks.com/discovery/matlab-mapreduce-hadoop.html