How do you reproduce bugs that occur sporadically?

前端 未结 28 1202
离开以前
离开以前 2021-01-30 19:43

We have a bug in our application that does not occur every time and therefore we don\'t know its \"logic\". I don\'t even get it reproduced in 100 times today.

Disclaime

相关标签:
28条回答
  • 2021-01-30 20:21

    There is no general good answer to the question, but here is what I have found:

    1. It takes a talent for this kind of thing. Not all developers are best suited for it, even if they are superstars in other areas. So know your team, who has a talent for it, and hope you can give them enough candy to get them excited about helping you out, even if it isn't their area.

    2. Work backwards, and treat it like a scientific investigation. Start with the bug, what you see is wrong. Develop hypotheses about what could cause it (this is the creative/imaginative part, the art that not everyone has the talent for) - and it helps a lot to know how the code works. For each of those hypotheses (preferably sorted by what you think is most likely - again pure gut feel here), develop a test that tries to eliminate it as the cause, and test the hypothesis. Any given failure to meet a prediction doesn't mean the hypothesis is wrong. Test the hypothesis until it is confirmed to be wrong (although as it gets less likely you may want to move on to another hypothesis first, just don't discount this one until you have a definitive failure).

    3. Gather as much data as you can during this process. Extensive logging and whatever else is applicable. Do not discount a hypothesis because you lack the data, rather remedy the lack of data. Quite often the inspiration for the right hypothesis comes from examining the data. Noticing something off in a stack trace, weird issue in a log, something missing that should be there in a database, etc.

    4. Double check every assumption. So many times I have seen an issue not get fixed quickly because some general method call was not further investigated, so the problem was just assumed to be not applicable. "Oh that, that should be simple." (See point 1).

    If you run out of hypotheses, that is generally caused by insufficient knowledge of the system (this is true even if you wrote every line of code yourself), and you need to run through and review code and gain additional insight into the system to come up with a new idea.

    Of course, none of the above guarantees anything, but that is the approach that I have found gets results consistently.

    0 讨论(0)
  • 2021-01-30 20:21

    What development environment? For C++, your best bet may be VMWare Workstation record/replay, see: http://stackframe.blogspot.com/2007/04/workstation-60-and-death-of.html

    Other suggestions include inspecting the stack trace, and careful code overview... there is really no silver bullet :)

    0 讨论(0)
  • 2021-01-30 20:22

    Add verbose logging. It will take multiple -- sometimes dozen(s) -- iterations to add enough logging to understand the scenario. Now the problem is that if the problem is a race condition, which is likely if it doesn't reproduce reliably, so logging can change timing and the problem will stop happening. In this case do not log to a file, but keep a rotating buffer of the log in memory and only dump it on disk when you detect that the problem has occurred.

    Edit: a little more thoughts: if this is a gui application run tests with a qa automation tool which allows you to replay macros. If this is a service-type app, try to come up with at least a guess as to what is happening and then programmatically create 'freak' usage patterns which would exercise the code that you suspect. Create higher than usual loads etc.

    0 讨论(0)
  • 2021-01-30 20:22

    I'd suggest to write down all things that user has been doing. If you have lets say 10 such bug reports You can try to find something that connects them.

    0 讨论(0)
  • 2021-01-30 20:23

    Unit Tests. Testing a bug in the app is often horrendous because there is so much noise, so many variable factors. In general the bigger the (hay)stack, the harder it is to pinpoint the issue. Creatively extending your unit test framework to embrace edge cases can save hours or even days of sifting

    Having said that there is no silver bullet. I feel your pain.

    0 讨论(0)
  • 2021-01-30 20:23

    "Heisenbugs" require great skills to diagnose, and if you want help from people here you have to describe this in much more detail, and patiently listen to various tests and checks, report result here, and iterate this till you solve it (or decide it is too expensive in terms of resources).

    You will probably have to tell us your actual situation, language, DB, operative system, workload estimate, time of the day it happened in the past, and a myriad of other things, list tests you did already, how they went, and be ready to do more and share the results.

    And this will not guarantee that we collectively can find it, either...

    0 讨论(0)
提交回复
热议问题