python: naming a module that has a two-word name

Question

I\'m trying to put together a really simple module with one .py source file in it, and have already run into a roadblock. I was going to call it scons-config but

Answer 1

Aside from PEP-8, you can also check out how the native Python modules deal with this issue.

If you were to compare the native modules of Python 2 to that of Python 3, you would see that the new tendency with the official devs is to avoid uppercase and underscores. For example, ConfigParser in Python 2 becomes configparser in Python 3.

Looking at this, the best course of action would be to avoid uppercase and underscores, and just join the words together, i.e. sconsconfig.

Answer 2

First, the module name is the same as the name of the single .py file. In Python-speak, a collection of several .py files is a package.

PEP-8 discourages breaking up package names with underscores. A quick peak at my site-packages directory shows that multiword names are commonly just run together (e.g., setuptools, sqlalchemy)

Module names (that is, file names) may be broken up by underscores (and I usually do this, because I hate namesthatruntogethersoyoucanhardlyreadthem).

Stick with lower-case only (per PEP-8). This avoids problems when going from case-sensitive to case-insensitive filesystems and vice versa.

Answer 3

- is a no go. The symbol is used for minus operator. The same is true in most programming languages. Use _ or otherwise nothing at all.

Answer 4

If you have to, always use underscores _.

Using a dot . would not even work, otherwise

from scons.config import whatever

would break.

But PEP 8 clearly describes it:

Package and Module Names

Modules should have short, all-lowercase names. Underscores can be used in the module name if it improves readability. Python packages should also have short, all-lowercase names, although the use of underscores is discouraged.

UPDATE:

To directly target your question: I think sconsconfig is fine. It is not too long and quite readable.

But honestly, I don't think anyone will blame you if you use underscores and your code will run with either decision. There is always a certain level where you should not care that much anymore.