UPDATED CODE
I\'m trying to figure out a way to count how often one value appears in an ArrayList.
System.out.println(\"Hand 1,
Collections.frequency
You have this feature already available from Collections class, in the frequency method.
public static int frequency(Collection<?> c, Object o)
That will return the number of occurrences of a specific object inside a collection.
Mind that without providing a vaild equals method this won't work or at least won't work with the equality you have in mind, since Java does't know your meaning of equality.