Compressing frames inside an AVI video

Question

I\'ve built a Windows Phone class to convert some WriteableBitmap into a AVI Full Frame (Uncompressed). Videos are really huge. Is there a simple codec implementation existing,

Answer 1

I take this to be a continuation/re-post of your previous question (but with a few more details). As I mentioned in the comments of that post, there is a whole universe of video codecs out there. One reason for the proliferation is that a lot of people like to re-invent wheels. However, a more salient reason is that there are a lot of different use cases for video.

You seem to be asking for a lot, yet there are a lot of variables you have not presented:

• You express a need for a video encoder that will run purely in software on a Windows Phone device, which is necessarily a fairly low-powered machine; do you need it to run in real-time? I.e., do you expect a frame of video to be compressed almost immediately after to send in the uncompressed frame (within a few milliseconds)? Or can you let the device think about the compression for awhile?
• How large are the video frames? Are you doing screen capture on a WP device, i.e., computer-generated data? Or are you reading raw frames from the camera and hoping to compress those?
• Following from the previous point, what type of video data? Computer-generated data will look better with a certain class of codecs. Photo-quality images (from camera) implies a different family of codecs.
• What bitrate are you aiming for? If you have 1 second of video, what's the max amount of bytes it should occupy (or so you hope)?
• Who is the eventual consumer of the video? In the last post, you indicated you wanted to upload to YouTube. If that's the case, you're in luck, since YouTube -- backed by FFmpeg -- handles nearly every codec in the universe, so you would have a lot of options.

I don't know much about Windows Phone programming. However, any WP device is going to technically have hardware video encoding capabilities. I've done some cursory Googling to determine if you get any access to that at the application programming level but I can't find any evidence that it's possible (and this SO answer states that the functionality is not there).

I hope to impress upon you that writing a video encoder is a LOT of work (look at my username; I know from whence I speak). Generally, they require quite a lot of CPU horsepower (and, consequently, battery power, especially when implemented in pure software). However, you have already made some guesses about a codec that uses standard zlib. In fact, there are a few video codecs based on straight zlib, namely MSZH and ZLIB, collectively the Lossless Codec Libraries. That wiki page has a basic bitstream description (disclosure: I operate that wiki site). I'm confident the WP libraries include access to zlib encoding, so this might be a starting point, and YouTube should be able to digest the resulting files.

There is also a video codec that combines XOR and zlib as you guessed (Dosbox Capture Codec), but it's probably not appropriate for your application.

Do the libraries provide access to standard JPEG (i.e., can it encode JPEG files)? Another option (depending on the video type) would be successive frames of still JPEG images stuffed in the AVI file. This is known as Motion JPEG or MJPEG. However, it's roughly equivalent in bitrate to intra-only MPEG-1, which you expressed as being inadequate.

I hope I have given you some ideas and useful avenues to pursue on your path to a solution.