Nesting 'IDisposable's in a single 'using' statement

Question

Quick question about using nested disposables in a single \'using\' statement: Should I write out each disposable\'s using statement, or can I nest them into one? Example:

Answer 1

It depends on the constructor, GZipStream disposes of the stream you passed in when you dispose of it unless you use one of the overloads that takes in a bool and you pass in true to leaveOpen.

However you do run a risk doing this. If GZipStream throws a ArgumentException because the CanRead property of the stream is false the passed in stream does not get disposed of.

Personally I rather not depend on "something not going wrong" and instead usually code defensively and use the 3 statement version.

---

Edit: Just to be clear, I'm not asking about nesting using statements. I'm asking whether or not an IDisposable that is created inside another IDisposable's 'using' statement will be disposed of at the end of the block. Any explanation on why or why not would be appreciated.

If that is your question then the answer is: No, only the object declared that was assigned to (using var whatever = ...) will be disposed, any other objects created are dependent on the code of whatever the "outer" object is to be implemented to "chain call" the Dispose() methods.

Answer 2

if when the block is done executing, the unnamed FileStream from "myFile.txt" gets cleaned up because it's in the using statement with the GZipStream

Even when both constructors succeed, it still depends on the design of the 'owning' class. A StreamReader will close its BaseStream but many other classes won't.

You don't want your code to depend on such murky and liable to change details.

Answer 3

Simple answer is no - you need to wrap every object.