Why is 'didset' called on a property when I set the property of that property?

Question

In this code when the text changes, titleEditingChanged is called (as expected). But when it executes the line

investment?.title = sender.text!         


        

Answer 1

It is called because Investment is probably a struct, not a class. In Swift structs are value types, not reference types as classes. So, structs are not "mutable in place".

It means that whenever you change a struct property a new struct object is allocated to replace the current one, the current object data is copied to the new one except for the changed property that will contain the new value set.

Remember that the compiler does not let you change a struct property whenever you initialize a struct object with a let command (with a class you can do it).

That explains why the observer is called whenever you change a struct property. Once a new struct object is allocated to replace the current one, it will now be stored in another memory block, so its value will be changed and the didSet observer will be called.

PS: It will not happen if you define Investment as a class instead of a struct.

Answer 2

Property observers of value types (e.g. structures) are called also when an underlying property of the type instance is set; simply since the value of the instance itself is updated. The same does not hold for reference types; as long as the reference itself is not mutated, the property observer will not be called (i.e., the reference itself can be considered the value of reference types).

From Language Guide - Properties - Property Observers we read:

Property observers observe and respond to changes in a property’s value. Property observers are called every time a property’s value is set, even if the new value is the same as the property’s current value

---

To verify the above, consider the following example:

/* reference type */
class InvestmentC {
    var title: String = "Foo"
}

/* value type */
struct InvestmentS {
    var title: String = "bar"
}

class InvestmentContainer {
    var investmentC : InvestmentC {
        didSet {
            print("did set a property of 'InvestmentC' instance (ref. type)")
        }
    }

    var investmentS : InvestmentS {
        didSet {
            print("did set a property of 'InvestmentS' instance (val. type)")
        }
    }

    init() {
        investmentC = InvestmentC()
        investmentS = InvestmentS()
    }
}

/* Example: property observer called only when setting a property
            of the value type instance 'investmentC'              */
let foo = InvestmentContainer()
foo.investmentC.title = "foobar" // prints: nothing
foo.investmentS.title = "foobar" // prints: "did set a property of 'InvestmentS' instance (val. type)"

---

Hence, we can infer that your custom type Investment is a value type (a structure), and the didSet property observer of the instance investment of this type (in your UITableViewCell subclass) will be called even if you only set/update underlying properties of investment. If you'd like to avoid this, change Investment into a reference type (class), in which case the didSet property observer will only be changed if the investment instance itself is set/updated.