Java + MySQL integrity violation handling

Question

I write Java program using JDBC (mysql database). When I violate mysql integrity (f.e. I try to insert same primary key value) I catch SQL exception. Should

Answer 1

There are two possible answers :

• if you know that your application is designed to avoid this kind of behaviour, use the exception
• if your application can make these errors often, use a test.

Answer 2

There are indeed basically two ways to achieve this:

1. Test if record exists before inserting --inside the same transaction.

2. Determine if SQLException#getSQLState() of the catched SQLException starts with 23 which is a constraint violation as per the SQL specification. It can namely be caused by more factors than "just" a constraint violation. You should not amend every SQLException as a constraint violation.

   public static boolean isConstraintViolation(SQLException e) {
       return e.getSQLState().startsWith("23");
   }
   

I would opt for the first one as it is semantically more correct. It is in fact not an exceptional circumstance. You namely know that it is potentially going to happen. But it may potentially fail in heavy concurrent environment where transactions are not synchronized (either unawarely or to optimize performance). You may then want to determine the exception instead.

That said, you normally shouldn't get a constraint violation on a primary key. In well designed datamodels which uses technical keys as primary keys they are normally to be managed by the database itself. Isn't the field supposed to be an unique key?

Answer 3

As others have mentioned that there are two possible approaches, one is to test and then insert/update otherwise handle SQL Exception. Both these approaches have their downsides:

• Caveat for "Test before inserting" is that every transaction will have additional queries which will impact performance. This is specially a bigger issue when such erroneous transactions are few in number.
• Caveat for "Evaluating SQL Exception" is that such exception messages are very database specific. These messages, most of the time, don't give specific information beyond stating that there is constrain violation.

So, I will propose an approach which is hybrid of the two.

• Don't perform the test before insert.
• Let database throw an exception.
• Catch SQL Exception.
• In the exception flow (catch block), do additional queries to form very specific error messages to indicate customers what has exactly failed (unique key, primary key, foreign key, specific columns etc).

This may require few additional lines of code but it definitely improves performance and generates friendly error messages.