Return type deduction in recursive function

Question

Following code compiles :

auto foo(int i) {
  if( i == 1 )
    return i;
  else 
    return foo(i-1)+i ; 
}

While following doesn\'t,

Answer 1

A recursive function can have an auto return type only if it has a non-recursive return statement before the recursive call. See Return type deduction for normal functions.

Answer 2

The first works because of this rule, 7.1.6.4/11 of the latest draft

Once a return statement has been seen in a function, however, the return type deduced from that statement can be used in the rest of the function, including in other return statements.

So the return type is deduced as int from the first return statement; the second is just checked to make sure that it also gives int, assuming that the recursive call does.

The second doesn't compile because the type of the expression depends on the return type; so the type can't be deduced.