Does the Python 3 interpreter leak memory when embedded?

Question

This bug report states that the Python interpreter, as of June 2007, will not clean up all allocated memory after calling Py_Finalize in a C/C++ application with an embedded

Answer 1

You can see that the bug (the first one, from 2007) is closed as "wontfix" by nnorwitz, and his post is in the bug report.

Why do you call Py_Initialize/Py_Finalize more than once? Why not do something like this (I'm kinda mixing C and Python for convenience):

/* startup */
Py_Initialize();

/* do whatever */
while (moreFiles()) {
    PyRun_SimpleString("execfile('%s')" % nextFile());
    /* do whatever */
}

/* shutdown */
Py_Finalize();

The problem is that most people who write Python modules don't worry about what happens if their module gets finalized and reinitialized, and often don't care about cleaning up during finalization. Module authors know that all memory is released when the process exits, and don't bother with anything more than that.

So it's not really one bug, it's really a thousand bugs -- one for each extension module. It's an enormous amount of work for a bug that affects a minority of users, most of whom have a viable workaround.

You can always just omit the call to Py_Finalize, calling Py_Initialize a second time is a no-op. This means your application will use additional memory usage when you first run a Python script, and that additional memory won't get returned to the OS until you exit. As long as you're still running Python scripts every once in a while, I wouldn't categorize it as a leak. Your application might not be Valgrind-clean, but it's better than leaking like a sieve.

If you need to unload your (pure) Python modules to avoid leaking memory, you can do that. Just delete them from sys.modules.

Drawbacks of Py_Finalize: If you are executing Python scripts repeatedly, it doesn't make much sense to run Py_Finalize between them. You'll have to reload all the modules every time you reinitialize; my Python loads 28 modules at boot.

Additional commentary: The bug is not limited to Python. A significant amount of the library code in any language will leak memory if you try to unload and reload libraries. Lots of libraries call into C code, lots of C programmers assume that their libraries gets loaded once and unloaded when the process exits.