Unpredictable Unique Identifier

Question

For an application I am working on, I need to generate a session token which must have following properties:

• it should be unique for the application at least,

Answer 1

Let me be very clear on this point. All of the answers saying to use a GUID are deeply wrong and you should not under any circumstances do so.

There is nothing whatsoever in the specification for GUIDs that requires that they be unpredictable by attackers. GUIDs are allowed to be sequential if allocated in blocks, GUIDs are allowed to be created with non-crypto-strength randomness, and GUIDs are allowed to be created from known facts about the world, like your MAC address and the current time. Nothing whatsoever requires that GUIDs be unpredictable.

If you need an unpredictable session key then generate one using a crypto strength random number generator to make sufficiently many bits.

More generally: use the right tool for the job particularly when it comes to security-impacting code. GUIDs were designed to make sure that two companies did not accidentally give the same identifier to two different interfaces. If that's your application, use a GUID for it. GUIDs were invented to prevent accidents by benign entities, not to protect innocent users against determined attackers. GUIDs are like stop signs -- there to prevent accidental collisions, not to protect against attacking tanks.

GUIDs were not designed to solve any problem other than accident prevention, so do not under any circumstances use them to solve crypto problems. Use a crypto library specifically designed to solve your problem, and implemented by world-class experts.

Answer 2

You could use the cryptographic RandomNumberGenerator and get however many bytes you want to generate an identifier of suitable length.

    RandomNumberGenerator rng = RandomNumberGenerator.Create();

    byte[] bytes = new byte[8];
    rng.GetBytes(bytes);

    // produces a string like "4jpKc52ArXU="
    var s = Convert.ToBase64String(bytes);

Answer 3

How about using what ASP.NET uses to generate unique, unpredictable and secure session ids:

using System;
using System.IO;
using System.Web;
using System.Web.SessionState;

class Program
{
    static void Main()
    {
        var request = new HttpRequest("", "http://localhost", "");
        var response = new HttpResponse(TextWriter.Null);
        var context = new HttpContext(request, response);
        var id = new SessionIDManager().CreateSessionID(context);
        Console.WriteLine(id);
    }
}

Answer 4

If you really and truly must have unpredictability, then generate a GUID and use a 128-bit bit mixer to rearrange the bits. Probably best to use a 64-bit bit mixer to mix the high and low portions. And, yes, there are bit mixers that guarantee unique output for every unique input.

Note that this isn't completely unpredictable. If somebody watching knows that the value is an obfuscated GUID, then he can probably examine successive values and, with some effort, potentially reverse-engineer your bit mixer.