Apple and private APIs

Question

Now that it\'s public knowledge that App Store submissions are being tested for use of private APIs, I need to ask the question... what exactly is a private API so that I ma

Answer 1

It's not just private APIs that can cause your application to get rejected. Using undocumented members of a public API can cause your application to get rejected. For example, the three20 library (since fixed) accessed _phase and other members of UITouch within a category.

They can also detect calls to private members via performSelector, as the following also flagged a rejection:

UIWindow* window = [UIApplication sharedApplication].keyWindow]
return !![window performSelector:@selector(firstResponder)];

More disturbing, if you make your application work under 3.1 and 3.0 and at runtime in 3.0 you don't use any of 3.1 stuff your application can still get rejected. An example might be the cameraOverlayView of UIImagePickerController (see here). This is kind of puzzling.

Answer 2

It is not difficult to get rejected by so called "using private API". Try to use the following as Core Data attribute and it would be rejected:

• colorIndex
• occurrence
• id

It shows how the robot scans the API.

Answer 3

You will find it difficult to use a private API by accident. They are not documented within the SDK docs, and they don't show up in XCode's code completion suggestions.

The reason this has become news recently is the creator of a framework used by several apps used a private API, so when developers who included his framework updated their apps, they were rejected (even though THOSE developers didn't use a private API, the framework they added to their application did).

That's about the only way you could possibly use a private API accidentally.

Answer 4

Generally by their absence from SDK headers. One of apple's conventions is to lead ObjC method names with underscores.

Answer 5

A great tool to use before you submit your app is App Scanner. It scans your .app file for private API usage and shows you what method signatures match up and what classes those methods are in.

link --> http://www.chimpstudios.com/appscanner/

Answer 6

My app was rejected by apple because of using private API.Here is code,

    Class UIKeyboardImpl = NSClassFromString(@"UIKeyboardImpl");

    id activeInstance = [UIKeyboardImpl performSelector:@selector(activeInstance)];

    [activeInstance performSelector:@selector(dismissKeyboard)];