Ember.js session cookie based authentication with Rails and devise

Question

I\'m looking to satisfy 3 goals with my Ember.js app authentication using rails, devise and a cookie based session.

1. Redirected to #/sessions/new i

Answer 1

I would not say this is not doable. But you will do lots of extra and unnecessary works to get the authentication working, which can all be done with a simple page redirect.

I've collected some opinions from Derick, the author of Backbone.Marionette. Though these are for Backbone but not Ember.js, the situation of client side authentication is same.

I find it painful and unnecessary to try and make Backbone/Marionette handle the authentication and re-loading of the authorized site stuff. Once they log in, redirect them to a different URL that the server handles, and have the server send down all the stuff that they need, as an authenticated user. https://stackoverflow.com/a/18151935

Another quote from Derick as well:

Right. And there’s a lot of cases where I just flat out say, “Do not do single-page applications,” as well. And a login screen is the biggest example of that. In all of the clients that I’ve had in the last couple of years, they’ve all asked me, “Hey, I’m having this problem. I’m trying to get my login screen to give me the current user information back from the server and redo all of this stuff on the screen without refreshing everything.” My answer every single time is, “Don’t do that." http://javascriptjabber.com/056-jsj-marionette-js-with-derick-bailey/

Also think about other cases, say Gmail. You won't get a smooth transition after click "Sign in" button on Gmail's sign in page. There will be redirect with rather big data loading as well :)

From users' perspective, they won't say Gmail is not great just because there is a redirect after signing in. After all signing/sign up is much much less frequent than daily mail operations.

So my suggestion is, reload all resources after user session changed. Let Rails and Devise do these dirty jobs in traditional fashion.