.Contains() method not calling Overridden equals method

Question

I am having an issue where I make an ArrayList of Foo objects, I override the equals method, and I cannot get the contains method to call the equals method. I have tried ove

Answer 1

This is because your equals() is not symmetric:

new Foo("ID1").equals("ID1");

but

"ID1".equals(new Foo("ID1"));

is not true. This violates the equals() contract:

The equals method implements an equivalence relation on non-null object references:

• [...]

• It is symmetric: for any non-null reference values x and y, x.equals(y) should return true if and only if y.equals(x) returns true.

It is not reflexive either:

• It is reflexive: for any non-null reference value x, x.equals(x) should return true.

Foo foo = new Foo("ID1");
foo.equals(foo)  //false!

@mbockus provides correct implementation of equals():

public boolean equals(Object o){
  if(o instanceof Foo){
    Foo toCompare = (Foo) o;
    return this.id.equals(toCompare.id);
  }
  return false;
}

but now you must pass instance of Foo to contains():

System.out.println(fooList.contains(new Foo("ID1")));
System.out.println(fooList.contains(new Foo("ID2")));
System.out.println(fooList.contains(new Foo("ID5")));

Finally you should implement hashCode() to provide consistent results (if two objects are equal, they must have equal hashCode()):

@Override
public int hashCode() {
    return id.hashCode();
}

Answer 2

You should implement hashCode

@Override
public int hashCode() {
    return id.hashCode();
}

even though the contains works for ArrayList without it. Your big problems are that your equals expects String, not Foo objects and that you ask for contains with Strings. If the implementation asked each eject in the list if they were equal to the string you send, then your code could work, but the implementation asks the string if it is equal to your Foo objets which it of course isn't.

Use equals

@Override
public boolean equals(Object o){
    if(o instanceof Foo){
        String toCompare = ((Foo) o).id;
        return id.equals(toCompare);
    }
    return false;
}

and then check contains

System.out.println(fooList.contains(new Foo("ID1")));

Answer 3

Your equals method needs to be altered along with overriding the hashCode() function. Currently you're checking to see if the object you're comparing to is an instanceof String, when you need to be checking for Foo objects.

public boolean equals(Object o){
    if(o instanceof Foo){
        Foo toCompare = (Foo) o;
        return this.id.equals(toCompare.id);
    }
    return false;
}

If you're using Eclipse, I would recommend having Eclipse generate the hashCode and equals for you by going to Source -> Generate hashcode() and equals()...