JavaFx scene lookup returning null

Question

Button btn = new Button(\"ohot\");
btn.setId(\"testId\");
itemSection.getChildren().add(btn);
Node nds = itemSection.lookup(\"‪#‎testId‬\");

What i

Answer 1

Lookups in conjunction with applyCSS

Lookups are based on CSS. So CSS needs to be applied to the scene for you to be able to lookup items in the scene. See the applyCSS documentation for more information. To get accurate results from your lookup, you might also want to invoke layout, as the layout operation can effect scene graph attributes.

So you could do this:

Button btn = new Button("ohot");
btn.setId("testId");
itemSection.getChildren().add(btn);
itemSection.applyCss();
itemSection.layout();
Node nds = itemSection.lookup("‪#‎testId‬");

Alternate lookup after showing a stage

Note that some operations in JavaFX, such as initially showing a Stage or waiting for a pulse to occur, will implicitly execute a CSS application, but most operations will not.

So you could also do this:

Button btn = new Button("ohot");
btn.setId("testId");
itemSection.getChildren().add(btn);
stage.setScene(new Scene(itemSection);
stage.show();
Node nds = itemSection.lookup("‪#‎testId‬");

On CSS based lookups VS explicit references

Storing and using explicit references in your code is often preferred to using lookups. Unlike a lookup, using an explicit reference is type safe and does not depend upon a CSS application. Generating explicit references can also be facilitated by using JavaFX and FXML with the @FXML annotation for type-safe reference injection. However, both lookup and explicit reference approaches have valid use cases, so it is a really just a matter of using the right approach at the right time.