Must declare function prototype in C? [duplicate]

Answer 1

In ANSI C (meaning C89 or C90), you do not have to declare a function prototype; however, it is a best practice to use them. The only reason the standard allows you to not use them is for backward compatibility with very old code.

If you do not have a prototype, and you call a function, the compiler will infer a prototype from the parameters you pass to the function. If you declare the function later in the same compilation unit, you'll get a compile error if the function's signature is different from what the compiler guessed.

Worse, if the function is in another compilation unit, there's no way to get a compilation error, since without a a prototype there's no way to check. In that case, if the compiler gets it wrong, you could get undefined behavior if the function call pushes different types on the stack than the function expects.

Convention is to always declare a prototype in a header file that has the same name as the source file containing the function.

In C99 or C11, standard C requires a function declaration in scope before you call any function. Many compilers do not enforce this restriction in practice unless you force them to do so.

Answer 2

it's not a must, if the function is defined before its use.

Answer 3

You should put function declarations in the header file (X.h) and the definition in the source file (X.c). Then other files can #include "X.h" and call the function.

Answer 4

It's not absolutely necessary to declare a function for the calling code to compile. There are caveats though. Undeclared function is assumed to return int and compiler will issue warnings first about function being undeclared and then about any mismatches in return type and parameter types.

Having said that it's obvious that declaring functions properly with prototypes is a much better practice.

Answer 5

It is not required, but it is bad practice not to use prototypes.

With prototypes, the compiler can verify you are calling the function correctly (using the right number and type of parameters).

Without prototypes, it's possible to have this:

// file1.c
void doit(double d)
{
    ....
}

int sum(int a, int b, int c)
{
    return a + b + c;
}

and this:

// file2.c

// In C, this is just a declaration and not a prototype
void doit();
int sum();

int main(int argc, char *argv[])
{
    char idea[] = "use prototypes!";

    // without the prototype, the compiler will pass a char *
    // to a function that expects a double
    doit(idea);

    // and here without a prototype the compiler allows you to
    // call a function that is expecting three argument with just
    // one argument (in the calling function, args b and c will be
    // random junk)
    return sum(argc);
}

Answer 6

It is never required to declare a prototype for a function in C, neither in "old" C (including C89/90) nor in new C (C99). However, there's a significant difference between C89/90 and C99 with regard to function declarations.

In C89/90 it was not necessary to declare a function at all. If the function is not declared at the point of the call, the compiler "guesses" (infers) the declaration implicitly from the types of the arguments passed in the call and assumes that the return type is int.

For example

int main() {
  int i = foo(5); 
  /* No declaration for `foo`, no prototype for `foo`.
     Will work in C89/90. Assumes `int foo(int)` */

  return 0;
}

int foo(int i) {
  return i;
}

In C99 every function that you call must be declared before point of the call. However, it is still not necessary to declare it with a prototype specifically. A non-prototype declaration will work as well. This means that in C99 the "implicit int" rule no longer works (for inferred function return types, in this case), but parameter types can still be guessed from the argument types if function is declared without a prototype.

The previous example will not compile in C99, since foo is not declared at the point of the call. Yet, you can add a non-prototype declaration

int foo(); /* Declares `foo`, but still no prototype */

int main() {
  int i = foo(5); 
  /* No prototype for `foo`, although return type is known. 
     Will work in C99. Assumes `int foo(int)` */

  return 0;
}
...

and end up with valid C99 code.

Nevertheless, it is always a good practice to declare a prototype for the function before you call it.

An additional note: I said above that it is never required to declare a function prototype. In fact, for some functions it is a requirement. In order to properly call a variadic function in C (printf for example) the function must be declared with a prototype before the point of the call. Otherwise, the behavior is undefined. This applies to both C89/90 and C99.