How to explain callbacks in plain english? How are they different from calling one function from another function?

后端 未结 30 1517
时光说笑
时光说笑 2020-11-22 11:13

How to explain callbacks in plain English? How are they different from calling one function from another function taking some context from the calling function? How can thei

相关标签:
30条回答
  • 2020-11-22 11:33

    In non-programmer terms, a callback is a fill-in-the-blank in a program.

    A common item on many paper forms is "Person to call in case of emergency". There is a blank line there. You write in someone's name and phone number. If an emergency occurs, then that person gets called.

    • Everyone gets the same blank form, but
    • Everyone can write a different emergency contact number.

    This is key. You do not change the form (the code, usually someone else's). However you can fill in missing pieces of information (your number).

    Example 1:

    Callbacks are used as customized methods, possibly for adding to/changing a program's behavior. For example, take some C code that performs a function, but does not know how to print output. All it can do is make a string. When it tries to figure out what to do with the string, it sees a blank line. But, the programmer gave you the blank to write your callback in!

    In this example, you do not use a pencil to fill in a blank on a sheet of paper, you use the function set_print_callback(the_callback).

    • The blank variable in the module/code is the blank line,
    • set_print_callback is the pencil,
    • and the_callback is your information you are filling in.

    You've now filled in this blank line in the program. Whenever it needs to print output, it will look at that blank line, and follow the instructions there (i.e. call the function you put there.) Practically, this allows the possibility of printing to screen, to a log file, to a printer, over a network connection, or any combination thereof. You have filled in the blank with what you want to do.

    Example 2:

    When you get told you need to call an emergency number, you go and read what is written on the paper form, and then call the number you read. If that line is blank nothing will be done.

    Gui programming works much the same way. When a button is clicked, the program needs to figure out what to do next. It goes and looks for the callback. This callback happens to be in a blank labeled "Here's what you do when Button1 is clicked"

    Most IDEs will automatically fill in the blank for you (write the basic method) when you ask it to (e.g. button1_clicked). However that blank can have any method you darn well please. You could call the method run_computations or butter_the_biscuits as long as you put that callback's name in the proper blank. You could put "555-555-1212" in the emergency number blank. It doesn't make much sense, but it's permissible.


    Final note: That blank line that you're filling in with the callback? It can be erased and re-written at will. (whether you should or not is another question, but that is a part of their power)

    0 讨论(0)
  • 2020-11-22 11:33

    Let's pretend you were to give me a potentially long-running task: get the names of the first five unique people you come across. This might take days if I'm in a sparsely populated area. You're not really interested in sitting on your hands while I'm running around so you say, "When you've got the list, call me on my cell and read it back to me. Here's the number.".

    You've given me a callback reference--a function that I'm supposed to execute in order to hand off further processing.

    In JavaScript it might look something like this:

    var lottoNumbers = [];
    var callback = function(theNames) {
      for (var i=0; i<theNames.length; i++) {
        lottoNumbers.push(theNames[i].length);
      }
    };
    
    db.executeQuery("SELECT name " +
                    "FROM tblEveryOneInTheWholeWorld " +
                    "ORDER BY proximity DESC " +
                    "LIMIT 5", callback);
    
    while (lottoNumbers.length < 5) {
      playGolf();
    }
    playLotto(lottoNumbers);
    

    This could probably be improved in lots of ways. E.g., you could provide a second callback: if it ends up taking longer than an hour, call the red phone and tell the person that answers that you've timed out.

    0 讨论(0)
  • 2020-11-22 11:34

    Callbacks are most easily described in terms of the telephone system. A function call is analogous to calling someone on a telephone, asking her a question, getting an answer, and hanging up; adding a callback changes the analogy so that after asking her a question, you also give her your name and number so she can call you back with the answer. -- Paul Jakubik , "Callback Implementations in C++"

    0 讨论(0)
  • Always better to start with an example :).

    Let's assume you have two modules A and B.

    You want module A to be notified when some event/condition occurs in module B. However, module B has no idea about your module A. All it knows is an address to a particular function (of module A) through a function pointer that is provided to it by module A.

    So all B has to do now, is "callback" into module A when a particular event/condition occurs by using the function pointer. A can do further processing inside the callback function.

    *) A clear advantage here is that you are abstracting out everything about module A from module B. Module B does not have to care who/what module A is.

    0 讨论(0)
  • 2020-11-22 11:35

    There's two points to explain, one is how a callback works (passing around a function that can be called without any knowledge of its context), the other what it's used for (handling events asynchronously).

    The analogy of waiting for a parcel to arrive that has been used by other answers is a good one to explain both. In a computer program, you would tell the computer to expect a parcel. Ordinarily, it would now sit there and wait (and do nothing else) until the parcel arrives, possibly indefinitely if it never arrives. To humans, this sounds silly, but without further measures, this is totally natural to a computer.

    Now the callback would be the bell at your front door. You provide the parcel service with a way to notify you of the parcel's arrival without them having to know where (even if) you are in the house, or how the bell works. (For instance, some "bells" actually dispatch a phone call.) Because you provided a "callback function" that can be "called" at any time, out of context, you can now stop sitting at the front porch and "handle the event" (of parcel arrival) whenever it's time.

    0 讨论(0)
  • 2020-11-22 11:35

    A callback is a function that will be called by a second function. This second function doesn't know in advance what function it will call. So the identity of the callback function is stored somewhere, or passed to the second function as a parameter. This "identity," depending on the programming language, might be the address of the callback, or some other sort of pointer, or it might be the name of the function. The principal is the same, we store or pass some information that unambiguously identifies the function.

    When the time comes, the second function can call the callback, supplying parameters depending on the circumstances at that moment. It might even choose the callback from a set of possible callbacks. The programming language must provide some kind of syntax to allow the second function to call the callback, knowing its "identity."

    This mechanism has a great many possible uses. With callbacks, the designer of a function can let it be customized by having it call whatever callbacks are provided. For example, a sorting function might take a callback as a parameter, and this callback might be a function for comparing two elements to decide which one comes first.

    By the way, depending on the programming language, the word "function" in the above discussion might be replaced by "block," "closure," "lambda," etc.

    0 讨论(0)
提交回复
热议问题