SQL Table Aliases - Good or Bad? [closed]

Answer 1

Am I the only person here who really hates them?

Generally, I don't use them unless I have to. I just really hate having to read something like

select a.id, a.region, a.firstname, a.blah, b.yadda, b.huminahumina, c.crap
from table toys as a
inner join prices as b on a.blah = b.yadda
inner join customers as c on c.crap = something else
etc

When I read SQL, I like to know exactly what I'm selecting when I read it; aliases actually confuse me more because I've got to slog through lines of columns before I actually get to the table name, which generally represents information about the data that the alias doesn't. Perhaps it's okay if you made the aliases, but I commonly read questions on StackOverflow with code that seems to use aliases for no good reason. (Additionally, sometimes, someone will create an alias in a statement and just not use it. Why?)

I think that table aliases are used so much because a lot of people are averse to typing. I don't think that's a good excuse, though. That excuse is the reason we end up with terrible variable naming, terrible function acronyms, bad code...I would take the time to type out the full name. I'm a quick typer, though, so maybe that has something to do with it. (Maybe in the future, when I've got carpal tunnel, I'll reconsider my opinion on aliases. :P ) I especially hate running across table aliases in PHP code, where I believe there's absolutely no reason to have to do that - you've only got to type it once!

I always use column qualifiers in my statements, but I'm not averse to typing a lot, so I will gladly type the full name multiple times. (Granted, I do abuse MySQL's tab completion.) Unless it's a situation where I have to use an alias (like some described in other answers), I find the extra layer of abstraction cumbersome and unnecessary.

Edit: (Over a year later) I'm dealing with some stored procedures that use aliases (I did not write them and I'm new to this project), and they're kind of painful. I realize that the reason I don't like aliases is because of how they're defined. You know how it's generally good practice to declare variables at the top of your scope? (And usually at the beginning of a line?) Aliases in SQL don't follow this convention, which makes me grind my teeth. Thus, I have to search the entire code for a single alias to find out where it is (and what's frustrating is, I have to read through the logic before I find the alias declaration). If it weren't for that, I honestly might like the system better.

If I ever write a stored procedure that someone else will have to deal with, I'm putting my alias definitions in a comment block at the beginning of the file, as a reference. I honestly can't understand how you guys don't go crazy without it.

Answer 2

Table aliases are a necessary evil when dealing with highly normalized schemas. For example, and I'm not the architect on this DB so bear with me, it can take 7 joins in order to get a clean and complete record back which includes a person's name, address, phone number and company affiliation.

Rather than the somewhat standard single character aliases, I tend to favor short word aliases so the above example's SQL ends up looking like:

select person.FirstName
      ,person.LastName
      ,addr.StreetAddress
      ,addr.City
      ,addr.State
      ,addr.Zip
      ,phone.PhoneNumber
      ,company.CompanyName
from tblPeople person
left outer join tblAffiliations affl on affl.personID = person.personID
left outer join tblCompany company on company.companyID = affl.companyID

... etc

Answer 3

Aliases are required when joining tables with columns that have identical names.

Answer 4

IMHO, it doesn't really matter with short table names that make sense, I have on occasion worked on databases where the table name could be something like VWRECOFLY or some other random string (dictated by company policy) that really represents users, so in that case I find aliases really help to make the code FAR more readable. (users.username makes a lot more sence then VWRECOFLY.username)

Answer 5

Well, there are some cases you must use them, like when you need to join to the same table twice in one query.

It also depends on wether you have unique column names across tables. In our legacy database we have 3-letter prefixes for all columns, stemming from an abbreviated form from the table, simply because one ancient database system we were once compatible with didn't support table aliases all that well.

If you have column names that occur in more than one table, specifying the table name as part of the column reference is a must, and thus a table alias will allow for a shorter syntax.

Answer 6

You need them if you're going to join a table to itself, or if you use the column again in a subquery...