Empty for loop - for(;;)

Question

I was exploring the Google Closure Compiler, and one thing I noticed was that it converts while(true) into for(;;).

Both do hang the browse

Answer 1

An empty middle part should be interpreted as true, so it's not falsy. It has the same semantics in C and other languages with that kind of loop (like C#, Java and so on). It would be a real trap to have changed it for JavaScript.

Answer 2

There is evaluation algorothm of for loop in Standard ECMA-262 script that says there are only two situations in which loop will end:

1. break statement
2. value of middle statement equal to false, but only if this statement is present, so it doesnt have to be necessary valuated as true (probably in mozilla js engine it is).

Answer 3

From the ECMAScript language specification:

IterationStatement : for (ExpressionNoIn_opt ; Expression_opt ; Expression_opt) Statement

If the first Expression is present, then

1. Let testExprRef be the result of evaluating the first Expression.
2. If GetValue(testExprRef) is false, return (normal, V, empty).

Since the first expression (the second argument to for) is not present, this section is never run, so the for loop does not exit.

Answer 4

No, it is not true.

See: https://developer.mozilla.org/en/JavaScript/Reference/Statements/for

condition

An expression to be evaluated before each loop iteration. If this expression evaluates to true, statement is executed. This conditional test is optional. If omitted, the condition always evaluates to true. If the expression evaluates to false, execution skips to the first expression following the for construct.

I should perhaps give a link to ECMAScript reference, but I'm pretty sure it states more or less same thing.