Select a Column in SQL not in Group By

Question

I have been trying to find some info on how to select a non-aggregate column that is not contained in the Group By statement in SQL, but nothing I\'ve found so far seems to

Answer 1

What you are asking, Sir, is as the answer of RedFilter. This answer as well helps in understanding why group by is somehow a simpler version or partition over: SQL Server: Difference between PARTITION BY and GROUP BY since it changes the way the returned value is calculated and therefore you could (somehow) return columns group by can not return.

Answer 2

The columns in the result set of a select query with group by clause must be:

• an expression used as one of the group by criteria , or ...
• an aggregate function , or ...
• a literal value

So, you can't do what you want to do in a single, simple query. The first thing to do is state your problem statement in a clear way, something like:

I want to find the individual claim row bearing the most recent creation date within each group in my claims table

Given

create table dbo.some_claims_table
(
  claim_id     int      not null ,
  group_id     int      not null ,
  date_created datetime not null ,

  constraint some_table_PK primary key ( claim_id                ) ,
  constraint some_table_AK01 unique    ( group_id , claim_id     ) ,
  constraint some_Table_AK02 unique    ( group_id , date_created ) ,

)

The first thing to do is identify the most recent creation date for each group:

select group_id ,
       date_created = max( date_created )
from dbo.claims_table
group by group_id

That gives you the selection criteria you need (1 row per group, with 2 columns: group_id and the highwater created date) to fullfill the 1st part of the requirement (selecting the individual row from each group. That needs to be a virtual table in your final select query:

select *
from dbo.claims_table t
join ( select group_id ,
       date_created = max( date_created )
       from dbo.claims_table
       group by group_id
      ) x on x.group_id     = t.group_id
         and x.date_created = t.date_created

If the table is not unique by date_created within group_id (AK02), you you can get duplicate rows for a given group.

Answer 3

You can do this with PARTITION and RANK:

select * from
(
    select MyPK, fmgcms_cpeclaimid, createdon,  
        Rank() over (Partition BY fmgcms_cpeclaimid order by createdon DESC) as Rank
    from Filteredfmgcms_claimpaymentestimate 
    where createdon < 'reportstartdate' 
) tmp
where Rank = 1

Answer 4

You can use as below,

Select X.a, X.b, Y.c from (
                Select X.a as a, sum (b) as sum_b from name_table X
                group by X.a)X
left join from name_table Y on Y.a = X.a

Example;

CREATE TABLE #products (
    product_name VARCHAR(MAX),
    code varchar(3),
    list_price [numeric](8, 2) NOT NULL
);

INSERT INTO #products VALUES ('paku', 'ACE', 2000)
INSERT INTO #products VALUES ('paku', 'ACE', 2000)
INSERT INTO #products VALUES ('Dinding', 'ADE', 2000)
INSERT INTO #products VALUES ('Kaca', 'AKB', 2000)
INSERT INTO #products VALUES ('paku', 'ACE', 2000)

--SELECT * FROM #products 
SELECT distinct x.code, x.SUM_PRICE, product_name FROM (SELECT code, SUM(list_price) as SUM_PRICE From #products 
               group by code)x
left join #products y on y.code=x.code

DROP TABLE #products

Answer 5

You can join the table on itself to get the PK:

Select cpe1.PK, cpe2.MaxDate, cpe1.fmgcms_cpeclaimid 
from Filteredfmgcms_claimpaymentestimate cpe1
INNER JOIN
(
    select MAX(createdon) As MaxDate, fmgcms_cpeclaimid 
    from Filteredfmgcms_claimpaymentestimate
    group by fmgcms_cpeclaimid
) cpe2
    on cpe1.fmgcms_cpeclaimid = cpe2.fmgcms_cpeclaimid
    and cpe1.createdon = cpe2.MaxDate
where cpe1.createdon < 'reportstartdate'

Answer 6

Thing I like to do is to wrap addition columns in aggregate function, like max(). It works very good when you don't expect duplicate values.

Select MAX(cpe.createdon) As MaxDate, cpe.fmgcms_cpeclaimid, MAX(cpe.fmgcms_claimid) As fmgcms_claimid 
from Filteredfmgcms_claimpaymentestimate cpe
where cpe.createdon < 'reportstartdate'
group by cpe.fmgcms_cpeclaimid