Importing two functions with same name using roxygen2

Question

I\'m a maintainer of a CRAN package and get the following messages when loading:

* checking whether package ‘qdap’ can be installed ... [10s/10s] WARNING
Fou         


        

Answer 1

Most likely no longer of use to you but maybe to others: the answer to your question can be found in the website you mention, in particular, here (quoting from source): "No matter how many times you use @importFrom foo bar".

So the correct use of roxygen2's tag @importFrom is: @importFrom package_name function_name. No commas, parenthesis, nothing, just the two names separated by a space (possibly applicable to more than 1 function, in the obvious way).

I have tried this myself just now when generating the documentation for the new version of one of my packages, so it should work.

I hope it helps.

Answer 2

The thing to keep in mind is that you cannot have more than one function with the same name in your package's namespace.

Suppose there are two packages, pkgA and pkgB, that both export a function called foo. If you create a package, pkgC, that has import(pkgA) and import(pkgB) in the NAMESPACE. Now, when you call library(pkgC) you'll get a warning:

replacing previous import 'foo' when loading 'pkgB'. 

Now, suppose someone creates another package, pkgD, that has this in the NAMESPACE file:

import(pkgA)
import(pkgB)
import(pkgC)

Then, library(pkgD) will give 2 warnings:

1: replacing previous import ‘foo’ when loading ‘pkgB’ 
2: replacing previous import ‘foo’ when loading ‘pkgB’ 

If everyone adopts the practice of importing entire namespaces, then 30 years from now, there will be a lot of these warnings.

Instead, since you can only have a single "foo" in your package, you should explicitly import the "foo" (and other functions) that you want your package to use. In the above example, the NAMESPACE for pkgD should be

importFrom(pkgB,foo)

If you actually need to use the two functions with the same name from two different packages, one hack you can perform is to import other functions from each package to ensure the packages are installed and their namespaces are loaded, but then refer to the functions you need using :: notation by placing this in your NAMESPACE:

importFrom(pkgA,foo)
importFrom(pkgB,bar)

and then calling functions pkgA::abc() and pkgB::abc() in your code.

Answer 3

Recently I've found a new way to tackle this problem. I want to import dplyr as well as data.table in development which gives these warnings. To remove the overlap functions, I used importFrom to import every function in data.table except for the overlaps.

ls("package:data.table") %>% 
  setdiff(c("last","first","between",":=")) %>% 
  str_c(collapse = " ")

## "%between% %chin% %flike% %ilike% %inrange% %like% address alloc.col as.data.table as.Date.IDate as.IDate as.ITime as.xts.data.table chgroup chmatch chorder CJ copy cube data.table dcast dcast.data.table fcoalesce fifelse fintersect foverlaps frank frankv fread frollapply frollmean frollsum fsetdiff fsetequal fsort funion fwrite getDTthreads getNumericRounding groupingsets haskey hour IDateTime indices inrange is.data.table isoweek key key<- key2 like mday melt melt.data.table merge.data.table minute month nafill quarter rbindlist rleid rleidv rollup rowid rowidv second set set2key set2keyv setalloccol setattr setcolorder setDF setDT setDTthreads setindex setindexv setkey setkeyv setnafill setnames setNumericRounding setorder setorderv shift shouldPrint SJ tables test.data.table timetaken transpose truelength tstrsplit uniqueN update.dev.pkg wday week yday year"

the setdiff have included all the conflicted function names. Last I importFrom data.table only the functions above.