Having tried a bunch of them (CodeReflect, Dis#, JustDecompile, ILSpy, dotPeek), one thing I realised is that most decompilers don't show you code in a very readable fashion. ILSpy is good, except that everything seem to be so cluttered. There are almost no new line at all between class members.
In that respect JustDecompile and dotPeek stand out. JustDecompile looks more polished with a slightly better interface to work with, except that it comes with a web installer, and you have to register as well in the process.
They all have strength and weaknesses, but my choice would be dotPeek which do not force you to register. It also comes with handy Visual Studio shortcuts which makes the whole experience familiar (for eg F12 to navigate to definition). With either of them you have a decent decompiler.
