Is it possible to use branch prediction hinting in C#?

Question

For example, I know it is defined for gcc and used in the Linux kernel as:

#define likely(x)       __builtin_expect((x),1)
#define unlikely(x)     __builtin_expe         


        

Answer 1

Short answer: No.

Longer Answer: You don't really need to in most cases. You can give hints by changing the logic in your statements. This is easier to do with a performance tool, like the one built into the higher (and more expensive) versions of Visual Studio, since you can capture the mispredicted branches counter. I realize this is for academic purposes, but it's good to know that the JITer is very good at optimizing your code for you. As an example (taken pretty much verbatim from CLR via C#)

This code:

public static void Main() {
    Int32[] a = new Int32[5];
    for(Int32 index = 0; index < a.Length; index++) {
        // Do something with a[index]
    }
}

may seem to be inefficient, since a.Length is a property and as we know in C#, a property is actually a set of one or two methods (get_XXX and set_XXX). However, the JIT knows that it's a property and either stores the length in a local variable for you, or inlines the method, to prevent the overhead.

...some developers have underestimated the abilities of the JIT compiler and have tried to write “clever code” in an attempt to help the JIT compiler. However, any clever attempts that you come up with will almost certainly impact performance negatively and make your code harder to read, reducing its maintainability.

Among other things, it actually goes further and does the bounds checking once outside of the loop instead of inside the loop, which would degrade performance.

I realize it has little to do directly with your question, but I guess the point that I'm trying to make is that micro-optimizations like this don't really help you much in C#, because the JIT generally does it better, as it was designed exactly for this. (Fun fact, the x86 JIT compiler performs more aggressive optimizations than the x64 counterpart)

This article explains some of the optimizations that were added in .NET 3.5 SP1, among them being improvements to straightening branches to improve prediction and cache locality.

All of that being said, if you want to read a great book that goes into what the compiler generates and performance of the CLR, I recommend the book that I quoted from above, CLR via C#.

EDIT: I should mention that if this were currently possible in .NET, you could find the information in either the EMCA-335 standard or working draft. There is no standard that supports this, and viewing the metadata in something like IlDasm or CFF Explorer show no signs of any special metadata that can hint at branch predictions.