LINQ Inner-Join vs Left-Join

Question

Using extension syntax I\'m trying to create a left-join using LINQ on two lists that I have. The following is from the Microsoft help but I\'ve modified it to show that the

Answer 1

Here's a good blog post that's just been posted by Fabrice (author of LINQ in Action) which covers the material in the question that I asked. I'm putting it here for reference as readers of the question will find this useful.

Converting LINQ queries from query syntax to method/operator syntax

Answer 2

Left joins in LINQ are possible with the DefaultIfEmpty() method. I don't have the exact syntax for your case though...

Actually I think if you just change pets to pets.DefaultIfEmpty() in the query it might work...

EDIT: I really shouldn't answer things when its late...

Answer 3

If you actually have a database, this is the most-simple way:

var lsPetOwners = ( from person in context.People
                    from pets in context.Pets
                        .Where(mypet => mypet.Owner == person.ID) 
                        .DefaultIfEmpty()
                     select new { OwnerName = person.Name, Pet = pets.Name }
                   ).ToList();

Answer 4

I think if you want to use extension methods you need to use the GroupJoin

var query =
    people.GroupJoin(pets,
                     person => person,
                     pet => pet.Owner,
                     (person, petCollection) =>
                        new { OwnerName = person.Name,
                              Pet = PetCollection.Select( p => p.Name )
                                                 .DefaultIfEmpty() }
                    ).ToList();

You may have to play around with the selection expression. I'm not sure it would give you want you want in the case where you have a 1-to-many relationship.

I think it's a little easier with the LINQ Query syntax

var query = (from person in context.People
             join pet in context.Pets on person equals pet.Owner
             into tempPets
             from pets in tempPets.DefaultIfEmpty()
             select new { OwnerName = person.Name, Pet = pets.Name })
            .ToList();

Answer 5

You need to get the joined objects into a set and then apply DefaultIfEmpty as JPunyon said:

Person magnus = new Person { Name = "Hedlund, Magnus" };
Person terry = new Person { Name = "Adams, Terry" };
Person charlotte = new Person { Name = "Weiss, Charlotte" };

Pet barley = new Pet { Name = "Barley", Owner = terry };
List<Person> people = new List<Person> { magnus, terry, charlotte };
List<Pet> pets = new List<Pet>{barley};

var results =
    from person in people
    join pet in pets on person.Name equals pet.Owner.Name into ownedPets
    from ownedPet in ownedPets.DefaultIfEmpty(new Pet())
    orderby person.Name
    select new { OwnerName = person.Name, ownedPet.Name };


foreach (var item in results)
{
    Console.WriteLine(
        String.Format("{0,-25} has {1}", item.OwnerName, item.Name ) );
}

Outputs:

Adams, Terry              has Barley
Hedlund, Magnus           has
Weiss, Charlotte          has

Answer 6

I the following error message when faced this same problem:

The type of one of the expressions in the join clause is incorrect. Type inference failed in the call to 'GroupJoin'.

Solved when I used the same property name, it worked.

(...)

join enderecoST in db.PessoaEnderecos on 
    new 
      {  
         CD_PESSOA          = nf.CD_PESSOA_ST, 
         CD_ENDERECO_PESSOA = nf.CD_ENDERECO_PESSOA_ST 
      } equals 
    new 
    { 
         enderecoST.CD_PESSOA, 
         enderecoST.CD_ENDERECO_PESSOA 
    } into eST

(...)