std::shared_ptr thread safety explained

Question

I\'m reading http://gcc.gnu.org/onlinedocs/libstdc++/manual/shared_ptr.html and some thread safety issues are still not clear for me:

1. Standard guarantees that

Answer 1

std::shared_ptr is not thread safe.

A shared pointer is a pair of two pointers, one to the object and one to a control block (holding the ref counter, links to weak pointers ...).

There can be multiple std::shared_ptr and whenever they access the control block to change the reference counter it's thread-safe but the std::shared_ptr itself is NOT thread-safe or atomic.

If you assign a new object to a std::shared_ptr while another thread uses it, it might end up with the new object pointer but still using a pointer to the control block of the old object => CRASH.

Answer 2

1. Correct, shared_ptrs use atomic increments/decrements of a reference count value.

2. The standard guarantees only one thread will call the delete operator on a shared object. I am not sure if it specifically specifies the last thread that deletes its copy of the shared pointer will be the one that calls delete (likely in practice this would be the case).

3. No they do not, the object stored in it can be simultaneously edited by multiple threads.

EDIT: Slight followup, if you want to get an idea of how shared pointers work in general you might want to look at the boost::shared_ptr source: http://www.boost.org/doc/libs/1_37_0/boost/shared_ptr.hpp.

Answer 3

As others have pointed out, you've got it figured out correctly regarding your original 3 questions.

But the ending part of your edit

Calling reset() in thread IV will delete previous instance of A class created in first thread and replace it with new instance? Moreover after calling reset() in IV thread other threads will see only newly created object?

is incorrect. Only d will point to the new A(10), and a, b, and c will continue to point to the original A(1). This can be seen clearly in the following short example.

#include <memory>
#include <iostream>
using namespace std;

struct A
{
  int a;
  A(int a) : a(a) {}
};

int main(int argc, char **argv)
{
  shared_ptr<A> a(new A(1));
  shared_ptr<A> b(a), c(a), d(a);

  cout << "a: " << a->a << "\tb: " << b->a
     << "\tc: " << c->a << "\td: " << d->a << endl;

  d.reset(new A(10));

  cout << "a: " << a->a << "\tb: " << b->a
     << "\tc: " << c->a << "\td: " << d->a << endl;
                                                                                                                 
  return 0;                                                                                                          
}

(Clearly, I didn't bother with any threading: that doesn't factor into the shared_ptr::reset() behavior.)

The output of this code is

a: 1 b: 1 c: 1 d: 1

a: 1 b: 1 c: 1 d: 10