Should DWORD map to int or uint?

Question

When translating the Windows API (including data types) into P/Invoke, should I replace DWORD with int or uint?

It\'s normally unsigned, but I

Answer 1

It's unsigned so map it to uint.

Answer 2

The CLS compliance warning applies only if the P/Invoke method is visible outside the assembly, which generally means the call is public. If the method is not externally visible, then it is acceptable to use uint.

Answer 3

Sadly,read Registry must use int otherwise throw exception.this microsoft code:

private static void Get45or451FromRegistry()
{
    using (RegistryKey ndpKey = RegistryKey.OpenBaseKey(RegistryHive.LocalMachine, RegistryView.Registry32).OpenSubKey("SOFTWARE\\Microsoft\\NET Framework Setup\\NDP\\v4\\Full\\")) {
        if (ndpKey != null && ndpKey.GetValue("Release") != null) {
            Console.WriteLine("Version: " + CheckFor45DotVersion((int) ndpKey.GetValue("Release")));
        }
      else {
         Console.WriteLine("Version 4.5 or later is not detected.");
      } 
    }
}

although release is REG_DWORD

Answer 4

According to official Platform invoke data types mapping table DWORD corresponds to System.UInt32 in C#.

Answer 5

Use int. Reason being, if I change "AutoRestartShell" with a uint variable:

regKey.SetValue("AutoRestartShell", uintVariable);

the data type in the Registry Editor changes to "REG_SZ". If I ask for that value to be returned with:

regKey.GetValue("AutoRestartShell");

a string gets returned.

If, however, I change "AutoRestartShell" with an int variable:

regKey.SetValue("AutoRestartShell", intVariable);

The data type stays as "REG_DWORD".

Why does this happen? No idea. All I know is that it does. Logic certainly would tell us that uint should be used but that changes the data type which we don't want.

Answer 6

A DWORD is, by (Microsoft's) definition, an unsigned 32-bit integer. It should map to whichever type your compiler uses to represent that.

These days it's most likely an unsigned int, but that's not a portable implementation. I know you're using C#, but to give you an example in a language I'm more familiar with, a typical implementation in C might be:

#if defined(SOME_HARDWARE_IMPLEMENTATION)
#define DWORD unsigned int
#elif #defined(SOME_OTHER_IMPLEMENTATION)
#define DWORD unsigned long
#elif #defined(YET_ANOTHER_IMPLEMENTATION)
#define DWORD something_else
#else
#error Unsupported hardware; cannot map DWORD
#endif