Pointer to vector vs vector of pointers vs pointer to vector of pointers

Question

Just wondering what you think is the best practice regarding vectors in C++.

If I have a class containing a vector member variable. When should this vector be declared a

Answer 1

Definitely the first!

You use vector for its automatic memory management. Using a raw pointer to a vector means you don't get automatic memory management anymore, which does not make sense.

As for the value type: all containers basically assume value-like semantics. Again, you'd have to do memory management when using pointers, and it's vector's purpose to do that for you. This is also described in item 79 from the book C++ Coding Standards. If you need to use shared ownership or "weak" links, use the appropriate smart pointer instead.