What makes Cassandra (and NoSQL in general) a better solution to an RDBMS?

Question

Well, NoSQL is a buzzword right now so I\'ve been looking into it. I\'m yet to get my head around ColumnFamilies and SuperColumns, etc... But I have been looking at how the data

Answer 1

If you are google, then you might be in a position where a NoSQL would be easier on you than a RDBMS. Since you are not, the many advantages an RDBMS provides you will probably be of some use. Significantly, on a single node, NoSQL offers absolutely no advantages over RDBMSes. RDBMSes offer lots of advantages over NoSQL, though. what are they?

RDBMSes use some pretty deep magic to understand the data it owns, and the data you are asking for, in such a way that it can return that data in the most efficient manner possible. If you didn't ask about some column, the rdbms doesn't waste any effort retrieving it. If you are interested in rows that have fields in common across two tables, (this is a join, btw), the RDBMS doesn't have to check every single pair of rows for matches, or what a NoSQL db usually does is just give you everything and make you do the checking. with a RDBMS, you can usually construct queries that are actually 'about' the data you are using, like "if the date is a tuesday", and if your indexes support it (if you do that query alot then you would add such an index) you can get those rows efficiently.

There is another reason why RDBMSes are nice. Transactions are easy on RDBMSes, but are much harder to get right on NoSQL databases. Supposing you are implementing a blogging engine. Suppose the post title (which appears in the URL) needs to be unique across all posts. In an RDBMS, you can easily be sure that you won't get this wrong accidentally. With a NoSQL database, if it does support some kind of transactional integrity, it's usually at the shard level, anything that could possibly require that kind of integrity must be on the same shard. since any pair of users could possibly be posting at the same moment, then every users' post must be on the same shard to get the same effect. Well, then you don't get any benefit at all from NoSQL.